Re: [talk-au] Consistent tagging of botanic gardens around Australia - leisure=park vs leisure=garden

2019-09-24 Thread Andrew Harvey
On Tue, 24 Sep 2019 at 10:58, Daniel Graus wrote: > Recently, the Sydney Royal Botanic Gardens were changed from > leisure=garden to leisure=park. This change prompted some discussion ( > https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/73984430) but no firm conclusions > really arose, with the gardens

Re: [talk-au] Discussion A: Is this forum fit for purpose?

2019-09-24 Thread Sebastian S.
Hi, I've said it before but this is not a forum. It is a mailing list. Therefore many of your points seem to have the wrong perspective. On 25 September 2019 9:00:50 am AEST, "Herbert.Remi via Talk-au" wrote: ># Discussion A: Is this forum fit for purpose? > > “PLEASE KEEP IT BRIEF. SPACE OF

Re: [talk-au] Consistent tagging of botanic gardens around Australia - leisure=park vs leisure=garden

2019-09-24 Thread Warin
On 24/09/19 20:56, Andrew Davidson wrote: On 24/9/19 10:56 am, Daniel Graus wrote: Should all botanical gardens be changed to match one another? Is leisure=park or leisure=garden more correct in some/the majority/all of these cases? OK, a quick global survey Of the ~2,500 botanical

Re: [talk-au] Discussion A: Is this forum fit for purpose?

2019-09-24 Thread Ben Kelley
You are missing one need: It needs to be something that people will use. For that reason, there are many ways to handle this, with the talk-au list being one of those. Some people use some of the other (existing) options for discussing OSM. A mailing list has its advantages and disadvantages,

[talk-au] Discussion A: Is this forum fit for purpose?

2019-09-24 Thread Herbert.Remi via Talk-au
# Discussion A: Is this forum fit for purpose? “PLEASE KEEP IT BRIEF. SPACE OF OF A PREMIUM. THANKS, JANE” ## The Issue The forum needs to be robust. It needs to tolerate a lot of traffic. It needs to work on the busy days, not just the quiet. It needs a functionality that allows you to

Re: [talk-au] Consistent tagging of botanic gardens around Australia - leisure=park vs leisure=garden

2019-09-24 Thread Andrew Davidson
On 24/9/19 10:56 am, Daniel Graus wrote: Should all botanical gardens be changed to match one another? Is leisure=park or leisure=garden more correct in some/the majority/all of these cases? OK, a quick global survey Of the ~2,500 botanical gardens that are in Wikidata and have a match