10 Jun 2019, 14:39 by frede...@remote.org:
> while it is *possible* to actually inspect every "upgrade"
> iD is suggesting, it is equally possible to just hit the "upgrade"
> button without caring at all and you can't see from the outside how much
> diligence has been applied in committing a
On Mon, 10 Jun 2019 at 22:41, Frederik Ramm wrote:
> It is possible for someone without any knowledge of Australia to
> participate in your challenge, log in, click the "upgrade tags" button
> without ever seeing *what* tags are being upgraded (or understanding
> why), and uploading the change.
Hi,
I'm a member of the OSMF Data Working Group and we have been alerted to
this thread. Please let me say a few words of caution to avoid problems
down the line:
The "upgrade tags" functionality in the ID editor is highly
controversial in the community. The rules about "upgrading" are not the
On Thu, Jun 6, 2019 at 2:32 PM Phil Wyatt wrote:
> PS – where it’s a building it wants to update each node of the building –
> not sure if this is a roulette issue or something else
>
>
>
That is annoying, I think its a maproullette issue - the queries look for
named nodes, named ways; when it
>
>
> For example my personal preference is to tag the
>
> name: brand + branch
>
> eg. so Westfield Chatswood is tagged
>
> name=Westfield Chatswood
> brand=Westfield
> branch=Chatswood
> brand:wikidata= -> wikidata for Westfield brand
> wikidata= -> wikidata for Westfield Chatswood
>
> Same
6 Jun 2019, 07:02 by p...@wyatt-family.com:
>
> 3) Are there any big negatives to this people can think of?
>
>
People doing it
- instead of significantly more useful mapping (adding brand:wikidata is not so
useful
to do it instead of mapping roads/shops/anything else)
- mindlessly, turning
I think doing this via MapRoulette challanges is a good way to go, and I
like that this can then be split up so only people with local knowledge are
editing as opposed to doing it without local knowledge.
I think care should be taken to not blindly "upgrade" all the tags, there
could be
PS – where it’s a building it wants to update each node of the building – not
sure if this is a roulette issue or something else
From: Daniel O'Connor [mailto:daniel.ocon...@gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, 6 June 2019 1:29 PM
To: OSM-Au
Subject: [talk-au] Maproullette challenge for feedback
be another good one given how they seem to be closing smaller
branches around the place – again at a state level.
Cheers - Phil
From: Daniel O'Connor [mailto:daniel.ocon...@gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, 6 June 2019 1:29 PM
To: OSM-Au
Subject: [talk-au] Maproullette challenge for feedback
Hey folks,
Since ID now includes some handy presets and some recommendations to
"upgrade tags", I thought I'd trial out a challenge to find all Woolworths
supermarkets without wikidata.
https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/8118
1) Is this kind of challenge and the resulting armchair mapping
10 matches
Mail list logo
