[Talk-ca] Accuracy of CanVec vs Yahoo?

2010-07-06 Thread G. Michael Carter
When importing the data do we favour yahoo existing data in OSM (which is obviously traced from satellite imagery) or CanVec? I'm assuming CanVec for parks would be based on official park boundaries rather than yahoo, line of site on open spaces. So parks would be better coming from CanVec.

Re: [Talk-ca] Accuracy of CanVec vs Yahoo?

2010-07-06 Thread Russell P
Around Vancouver I have found CanVec buildings to be quite inaccurate, so i would use Yahoo there. Best to do some mapping on the ground though with your GPS so you can be sure that Yahoo is properly rectified because I know quite a few areas in my neighborhood where yahoo imagery is off by like

Re: [Talk-ca] Accuracy of CanVec vs Yahoo?

2010-07-06 Thread Tyler Gunn
On Tue, 06 Jul 2010 12:11:40 -0400, G. Michael Carter mi...@carterfamily.ca wrote: When importing the data do we favour yahoo existing data in OSM (which is obviously traced from satellite imagery) or CanVec? I'm assuming CanVec for parks would be based on official park boundaries rather

Re: [Talk-ca] Accuracy of CanVec vs Yahoo?

2010-07-06 Thread Richard Weait
On Tue, Jul 6, 2010 at 6:11 PM, G. Michael Carter mi...@carterfamily.ca wrote: When importing the data do we favour yahoo existing data in OSM (which is obviously traced from satellite imagery)  or CanVec?   I'm assuming CanVec for parks would be based on official park boundaries rather than

Re: [Talk-ca] Accuracy of CanVec vs Yahoo?

2010-07-06 Thread Sam Vekemans
Hi, There is also the Spot5 imagery :) and the CanTopo geoTIFFs to compare. for those parks that i origionally converted, you need to compare with CanTopo as that is more accurate. and as Russel and Tyler Just mentioned. It's really a combo of both. and check the local GPS tracks this is

Re: [Talk-ca] Accuracy of CanVec vs Yahoo?

2010-07-06 Thread Bégin , Daniel
From: talk-ca-boun...@openstreetmap.org [mailto:talk-ca-boun...@openstreetmap.org] On Behalf Of G. Michael Carter Sent: 6 juillet 2010 12:12 To: talk-ca@openstreetmap.org Subject: [Talk-ca] Accuracy of CanVec vs Yahoo? When importing the data do we favour yahoo existing