Re: [Talk-ca] Nova Scotia imports, and boundary=land_area

2018-11-01 Thread John Whelan
Are you confusing the availability of Open Data with an import?  Most imports need plans but just because Open Data is available does not mean the license is compatible nor that it will be imported. My feeling is the wiki page lists open data and indicates if the license is compatible. We

Re: [Talk-ca] Nova Scotia imports, and boundary=land_area

2018-11-01 Thread John Whelan
The Canadian Federal Government Open Data License is one of the few that has been formally approved by the legal working group.  I would have preferred to see it released through the Treasury Board's Open Data portal that way there is no question about the license but I accept Alessandro's

Re: [Talk-ca] Nova Scotia imports, and boundary=land_area

2018-11-01 Thread OSM Volunteer stevea
On Nov 1, 2018, at 12:47 PM, Дмитрий Киселев wrote: > Looks like the wiki needs amending to only list open data with the correct > license either separately or a note added to each entry. Mmmm, not "only," an Import Plan is required, too. That can be part of a wiki that describes the project

Re: [Talk-ca] Nova Scotia imports, and boundary=land_area

2018-11-01 Thread Дмитрий Киселев
Hi John, Looks like the wiki needs amending to only list open data with the correct > license either separately or a note added to each entry. what's the status of OGL-CA is it compatible or not, or compatible with some restrictions or only for some datasets? StatsCan just published building

Re: [Talk-ca] Open Database of Buildings / Base de données ouvertes sur les immeubles

2018-11-01 Thread Alasia, Alessandro (STATCAN)
Hi Janes, John and all, Sure, it will be up to the OSM community to discuss, decide and organize as deemed appropriate. The data are out there, released under one single open data lincese! (Open Government License - Canada) My hope is

Re: [Talk-ca] Open Database of Buildings / Base de données ouvertes sur les immeubles

2018-11-01 Thread OSM Volunteer stevea
Additionally, the greater OSM community looks forward to your Import Plan that follows our Import Guidelines ( https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines ). Regards, SteveA California > On Nov 1, 2018, at 11:22 AM, John Whelan wrote: > > I think on the OSM side we probably need to

Re: [Talk-ca] Open Database of Buildings / Base de données ouvertes sur les immeubles

2018-11-01 Thread John Whelan
I think on the OSM side we probably need to think this one through and get organised. In Ottawa on the first import we went through all the steps to do the import including getting agreement with the local mappers and we were very fortunate in having an organised team of competent local

Re: [Talk-ca] Open Database of Buildings / Base de données ouvertes sur les immeubles

2018-11-01 Thread James
We were actually talking about that on the osmcanada slack channel this morning. If we wanted to use said data it would have to be evaluated city by city not as a whole data source. There are providers(Ottawa, Yellowknife, Montreal for example) that are already pretty well mapped in OSM where

[Talk-ca] Open Database of Buildings / Base de données ouvertes sur les immeubles

2018-11-01 Thread Alasia, Alessandro (STATCAN)
Released today! / Diffusée aujourd’hui Share with your networks ! / Partagez avec vos réseaux ! ***(EN) Open Building Data: an exploratory initiative This exploratory initiative aims at enhancing the use and harmonization of open building data from government sources for the purpose of

Re: [Talk-ca] Dartmouthmapmaker

2018-11-01 Thread Andrew Lester
I'm not sure how helpful that article would be, considering that it focuses on building tagging, but this user is primarily working on admin boundaries and highways. John, I'm surprised that you were able to successfully have a discussion with them. A number of other contributors have tried

Re: [Talk-ca] Dartmouthmapmaker

2018-11-01 Thread OSM Volunteer stevea
Being as gentle (though not local) as I can be, I continue to assert that our wiki for BC2020 in general and https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/WikiProject_Canada/Building_Canada_2020#The_data_that_could_be_mapped as a specific section IN that wiki (calling attention to these tags, with

[Talk-ca] Dartmouthmapmaker

2018-11-01 Thread john whelan
I've discussed the Open Data side with them but I think they could do with a bit of guidence on the tagging side. Could someone ideally more local than I point them gently towards map features and more standard tagging? I must confess my knowledge of tagging is a little limited to highways and