On 18 January 2020 at 1340, Cj Malone wrote:
> Although now I have another issue, which data source should be preferred.
Whichever is the most up-to-date in your area. NaPTAN data has a
ModificationDateTime field which shows when it was last updated. The SV data
doesn't have such info so you'd
For an example of possible name mismatch, see the edit history for node:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/485404488 which is shown at
https://flic.kr/p/2igLCco
For an example of stops being amalgamated see:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/435846038 when
Hey Neil,
I don't know which nodes you are talking about, but of the ones I'm
looking at (where "name" != name from new NaPTAN data using
"naptan:AtcoCode"). The vast majority haven't been updated in 10 years,
since the NaPTAN import, or one edit where "naptan:verified" was
changed to yes.
I am
No, please don't update mismatched bus stop names "blindly".
I've surveyed a lot locally and have updated them to the newest values
from paper timetables -- which have newer names than on metal signage.
They also match the names that the local council have used when updating
OSM. A lot of names
If you take a look at the map for the area, you’ll see that Redwood Close is a
close to the east, on the bend in Mountbatten Drive. The bus stop, as can be
seen should you happen to look at a site where there is some street imagery
(can’t imagine which one) is actually where NaPTAN has it -
Thanks, I didn't really understand the NaPTAN site, but your link to download
the data really helped.
Although now I have another issue, which data source should be preferred. Take
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/550691387 for example, no name in OSM. It's
napcode appears to be 23062,
Hi Guys
I imported NaPTAN data for my local area (Chorley) some months ago. Took
the data for Lancashire and filtered on Town:Chorley. Some of the stops
were excluded because the data had not been correctly input by reason of
no entry, misspelt, wrong town entered.
Using the JOSM:Conflate
Hi Cj,
What you have got there is Southern Vectis’s link to a subset of the current
NaPTAN data. Please note, though, that Southern Vectis are not responsible for
this data - that is maintained by Isle of Wight Council.
NaPTAN data is always available by local authority, or for the entire
Hello,
I've recently found an open data set with more accurate bus stop names
than OSM. Based on my limited survey of differences in OSM data and
this data, theirs has been more accurate. Not really surprising, since
it's there network, and most of the OSM data hasn't been updated since
the
9 matches
Mail list logo