[Talk-transit] Re: GTFS compatibility

2010-06-30 Thread Hillsman, Edward
Our center has a project to explore the use of OSM as a repository and tool for supporting multimodal trip planners (for example, bike to transit, ride the bus, walk or bike to final destination). We are keenly interested in the current discussion of transit and GTFS in OSM, because one of our

Re: [Talk-transit] GTFS compatibility

2010-06-30 Thread Joe Hughes
Ed, Great to see someone from the CUTR efforts chiming in here. Just to clarify one point, when you say locational errors in GTFS, you're referring to issues with the source data from the particular agencies that you're working with, rather than anything having to do with the representation

Re: [Talk-transit] GTFS compatibility

2010-06-30 Thread john whelan
I'm currently looking at Bus stops in Ottawa in OSM and finding similar issues with the existing bus_stops. I'm seriously wondering where stop_codes exist if one approach might be to import bus_stops using GTFS data and use the GTFS tags such as stop_code etc from stops.txt

Re: [Talk-transit] GTFS compatibility

2010-06-30 Thread Joe Hughes
Many transport agencies/operators still don't have rider-facing stop codes, and some may have them for only a subset of their stops. However, as you say, where they *are* present, they present the most stable dataset-local identifier for stop, if only because of the costs involved in changing