Re: [Talk-us] [Imports] TriMet will begin OSM improvements in the Portland area

2011-03-03 Thread Kate Chapman
Hi Tom, Could you post a link to the area you imported? Not all tags are rendered in the default Mapnik styling. Maybe we could help figure out exactly what is going one. Thanks, Kate user:wonderchook On Tue, Mar 1, 2011 at 7:17 PM, Tom Ponte t...@bendbroadband.com wrote: PJ, I would be

Re: [Talk-us] [Imports] TriMet will begin OSM improvements in the Portland area

2011-03-03 Thread PJ Houser
Hi Tom, First, let me say that ESRI has been great regarding the OSM Editor. I contacted them with our problems, they responded within minutes, and now we're working together on determining if our problems are operator-based or editor-based. We encountered 5 main problems: 1) Revision table

Re: [Talk-us] TriMet will begin OSM improvements in the Portland area

2011-03-03 Thread PJ Houser
Hi Alan, The aerials are currently for jurisdictional use only. There does seem to be a push for making data public - maybe someday they will be available. I don't know. We are using the aerials to determine the accuracy of OSM and RLIS, so we just use it as a background layer. In some cases,

Re: [Talk-us] Talk-us Digest, Vol 40, Issue 3

2011-03-03 Thread PJ Houser
Paul, ArcMap OSMEditor became the tool of choice because: 1) ArcMap has powerful editing and geoprocessing capabilities. 2) Our jurisdictional data are in shapefiles, and ArcMap deals well with shapefiles. 3) The interns are most familiar with ArcMap. We did consider using a single

Re: [Talk-us] TriMet will begin OSM improvements in the Portland area

2011-03-03 Thread Alan Mintz
IANAL, but this tickles my derivative work sensor a little. How would this be any different than using Google, or another copyrighted imagery source? If a road, intersection, or feature is moved in OSM as a result of looking at its position in the imagery, is that not deriving from the imagery?

Re: [Talk-us] TriMet will begin OSM improvements in the Portland area

2011-03-03 Thread Alan Mintz
I wrote: IANAL, but this tickles my derivative work sensor a little. How would this be any different than using Google, or another copyrighted imagery source? If a road, intersection, or feature is moved in OSM as a result of looking at its position in the imagery, is that not deriving from

Re: [Talk-us] TriMet will begin OSM improvements in the Portland area

2011-03-03 Thread PJ Houser
Hi Alan, Let me forward this to my employer for more clarification. I'm thinking that the Trimet interns (I'm included in that group) can use it because we are also checking RLIS data to make sure it is correct, and for that, we definitely need the aerials. I'll get back to you on this. I was

[Talk-us] Trimet updates to OSM in Portland, Oregon area - workflow

2011-03-03 Thread PJ Houser
Regarding the updates to OSM by 4 Trimet interns, in 4 counties around Portland, Oregon... Our updated workflow is still in testing, but we have found this to work, albeit, slowly. Using ArcMap 10, we are creating reference geodatabases in which to organize and store our jurisdictional data. -