Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-08-25 Thread Jerry Clough - OSM
housing discrimination. ... | | | | From: Peter Dobratz <pe...@dobratz.us> To: Albert Pundt <roadsgu...@gmail.com> Cc: "talk-us@openstreetmap.org" <talk-us@openstreetmap.org> Sent: Thursday, 27 July 2017, 18:29 Subject: Re: [Talk-us] Pittsb

Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-07-27 Thread Albert Pundt
Why are townships, boroughs, towns, and cities in PA mapped with separate admin levels, or at least "supposed to be" mapped that way according to that page? As far as I know they're always only ever one level below county, and never overlap. i.e. you never have a town in the middle of some other

Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-07-27 Thread OSM Volunteer stevea
OK, three topics shake out from this, two Pennsylvania, one Boston. I'll try (and likely fail) to be brief: 1) Pittsburgh's neighborhoods, now entered and tagged admin_level=9, seem like they are better entered as admin_level=10, to harmonize with neighborhoods in many other states.

Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-07-27 Thread Bill Ricker
​ ​> , "about 41 out of 50" states (leaving 9) were believed correct as described in that table. (And, that was posted here). > On July 10, Peter Dobratz and I (among others) submitted the six New England states (of those 9) in a sub-table, which I harmonized into that wiki's "Big Table."

Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-07-27 Thread Peter Dobratz
(Appologies as I was in the middle of writing my reply when inadvertantly hitting send. Here's the whole message) Boundaries below admin_level=8 are still being discussed. There was some discussion on this list as well as the OSM wiki https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:United_States_

Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-07-27 Thread OSM Volunteer stevea
> Albert Pundt writes > I noticed that the neighborhoods in Pittsburgh are mapped as administrative > boundaries with admin_level=9. Is this proper? The wiki page for U.S. admin > levels doesn't list any use for admin level 9 in Pennsylvania, though this > seems appropriate if Pittsburgh

Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-07-27 Thread Peter Dobratz
Boundaries below admin_level=8 are still being discussed. There was some discussion on this list as well as the OSM wiki https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:United_States_admin_level#Nine_state_improvement Having lived in Pittsburgh, I remember that the neighborhood boundaries are well

Re: [Talk-us] Pittsburgh neighborhood boundaries mapped with admin level 9?

2017-07-26 Thread Bill Ricker
IDK Pittsburgh but City of Boston has semiofficial neighborhoods that sort of qualify as subordinate administrative units, in that there are official city hall neighborhood service offices and official borders. OTOH some of our official neighborhoods are 10x or more large than others (in both pop