Re: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do?

2012-05-16 Thread Louis E. Schmier
I don't know Dave. Yeah, I'm no scholar in psychology, even if it was one of my college minors, but I do have 45 years of being a boots-on-the-ground classroom grunt, and as a consequence I just no longer go blindly for Skinner's rat-like attitude towards people with a "do this and you'll get t

Re:[tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do?

2012-05-15 Thread Allen Esterson
An alternative to the kind of psychotherapy practised by some of those quoted in the article in the WSJ is enunciated in one of the online comments, from Dr Michael DeMarco: "There are lots of therapists who will gladly let you come to their office one (or 3- I'm looking at you, psychoanalysts)

Re: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do?

2012-05-15 Thread Michael Palij
On Tue, 15 May 2012 15:24:53 -0700, Christopher Green wrote: >Well, this doesn't sound much like therapy at all, but just the kind of >unhelpful advice one gets from a bad boss. That said, it also sounds a fair bit >like Albert Ellis, which isn't new at all. (Indeed, Ellis said he was just >reworki

Re: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do?

2012-05-15 Thread Dr. Bob Wildblood
00 >From: Christopher Green >Subject: Re: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do? >To: "Teaching in the Psychological Sciences (TIPS)" > >Well, this doesn't sound much like therapy at all, but just the kind of unhelpful advice one gets from a bad boss. That said, it als

RE: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do?

2012-05-15 Thread Lilienfeld, Scott O
) Subject: Re: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do? Well, this doesn't sound much like therapy at all, but just the kind of unhelpful advice one gets from a bad boss. That said, it also sounds a fair bit like Albert Ellis, which isn't new at all. (Indeed, Ellis said he was just reworking Stoici

Re: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do?

2012-05-15 Thread Christopher Green
Well, this doesn't sound much like therapy at all, but just the kind of unhelpful advice one gets from a bad boss. That said, it also sounds a fair bit like Albert Ellis, which isn't new at all. (Indeed, Ellis said he was just reworking Stoicism for the 20th century.) Chris ... Christopher

RE: [tips] What Would Carl Rogers Do?

2012-05-15 Thread David T. Wasieleski
Michael: You ask what would Carl Rogers do, a bit as if that's the ideal of therapy. As I'm sure you're aware there are many models of therapy, and Rogers introduced some essential components to any good therapist's arsenal. But most forms of therapy eschew "unconditional positive regard" for a