Re: Topband: Real World logging issues

2023-11-30 Thread Mike Fatchett W0MU
After being DX many times, mistakes happen.  About 1/2 took place prior to online logs.  For my operations this has been a very tiny issue.  My choice before online logs was that I would wait for a period of time to see if the station in the log actually requested a QSL.  I might have even

Re: Topband: Real World logging issues

2023-11-30 Thread W3HKK
Am enjoying comments from DXers about real world/160m/marginal copy, and can only imagine the challenges faced. My kudos to you for making the valiant effort! One obvious but simple check an op can do, after finding HIS call is not in the DX's log, is to check whether that call is in the FCC

Re: Topband: What is a valid CW contact

2023-11-30 Thread Tim Shoppa
When you're trying to work a DXpedition outside a contest, I see no problem with checking live log and working them again until they get your call right. Things are different in a contest. I don't think contesters should be checking live logs. Quoting some rules: CQ 160: "Do not arrange or

Re: Topband: What is a valid CW contact

2023-11-30 Thread Wes Stewart via Topband
My sentiments exactly. Wes  N7WS On Thursday, November 30, 2023 at 11:10:16 AM MST, Ron Spencer via Topband wrote: I've never been DX (well, USVI but that's not rare nor hard to get to) so can't give a perspective from that viewpoint.  My thinking is this: you either got my call

Topband: What is a valid CW contact

2023-11-30 Thread Ron Spencer via Topband
I've never been DX (well, USVI but that's not rare nor hard to get to) so can't give a perspective from that viewpoint.  My thinking is this: you either got my call 100% right, or you didn't. Same standard as in a contest. If you logged something other than my call, then I didn't have a