[topbraid-users] shacl versus owl/cwa

2018-12-04 Thread 'Bohms, H.M. (Michel)' via TopBraid Suite Users
Dear all, When trying to promote shacl we typically run into the question: Why can't we just use OWL with CWA-interpretation (incl. non-UNA)? Some reasoners even have a "switch". We then say: * Shacl (core) is more powerful * Shacl will later (when?) cover shacl-af for rules, so

Re: [topbraid-users] shacl versus owl/cwa

2018-12-04 Thread Irene Polikoff
One reason would be that there is no standard CWA-interpretation of RDFS/OWL. Such semantics is not defined. Of course, one could decide how it should work, but it would be their own decision or a decision of a vendor who has such “switch capability”.. With two different interpretation of the

[topbraid-users] Handling text files in EDG

2018-12-04 Thread rob . atkinson
Is there a sensible way to manage a text file in EDG? One option would be the equivalent of SXML - where every line is an entitiy with a line number and string value - and its a matter of ordering to recreate. (i.e. if a SPARQLmotion script is appending to a file in a loop, can I make it