Re: Help us review #MesosCon 2015 proposals

2015-02-21 Thread Dave Lester
Hi Tim, There's no magic number, but that's being discussed by the speaker subcommittee now and it's something the larger MesosCon program committee will need to decide in the coming weeks. The # of accepted talks will largely depend on the number of tracks we break into, and number of / length

Re: Help us review #MesosCon 2015 proposals

2015-02-21 Thread Steve Domin
All of them look great indeed. Didn't reject any as well. I find the wording a bit annoying as I didn't really find any talk average, I just selected accept for the one I really want to hear about more than anything else. On Saturday, February 21, 2015, Pablo Delgado pabl...@gmail.com wrote:

Re: Help us review #MesosCon 2015 proposals

2015-02-21 Thread Dave Lester
Thanks Steve and Pablo for the feedback. Regarding the system of rating proposals: this is similar to what we used last year, however last year we also had strongly accept and strongly reject options which in my personal opinion were helpful for determining the best-of-the-best. As a speaker

Re: Help us review #MesosCon 2015 proposals

2015-02-20 Thread Benjamin Mahler
Great to see so many proposals! Is it intentional that we have to review them in small subsets? It's hard to tell what to consider as an Average proposal when you can only see a small subset at a time. Just curious on the reasoning behind that. On Wed, Feb 18, 2015 at 2:44 PM, Dave Lester

Re: Help us review #MesosCon 2015 proposals

2015-02-20 Thread Jie Yu
+1 It does not allow me to continue to see the second page if I don't make choices on the first one. - Jie On Fri, Feb 20, 2015 at 4:54 PM, Benjamin Mahler benjamin.mah...@gmail.com wrote: Great to see so many proposals! Is it intentional that we have to review them in small subsets? It's

Re: Help us review #MesosCon 2015 proposals

2015-02-20 Thread Pablo Delgado
Maybe a scale of 1 to 5 makes more sense. I did Accept on ALL talks but 3 that consider Average but only on the basis of repeated subject. Did not reject Anything. I wonder how the selection is going to be made, since all of them are great talks! On Fri, Feb 20, 2015 at 9:59 PM, Jie Yu

Help us review #MesosCon 2015 proposals

2015-02-18 Thread Dave Lester
A total of 63 proposals were submitted for #MesosCon[1], up significantly from 24 submitted for last year’s conference. Similar to last year, the MesosCon program committee is opening these proposals up for community review/feedback to better-inform our decisions about what should be included in