Re: inconsistencies between browsers/OSs
Hi, Am Donnerstag, den 02. April 2020 um 21:23:16 Uhr (+0200) schrieb YUP: > Hi, it could be a problem of UDP ports. Can you check whether UDP > ports are open or close in your firewall? For the turnserver we have this: ACCEPT udp -- anywhere anywhere udp spts:49152:65535 dpts:49152:65535 ACCEPT tcp -- anywhere anywhere tcp dpt:3478 ACCEPT udp -- anywhere anywhere udp dpt:3478 ACCEPT tcp -- anywhere anywhere tcp dpt:5349 ACCEPT udp -- anywhere anywhere udp dpt:5349 In our turnserver.conf the default min-port=49152 and max-port=65535 settings were commented out. I removed the comment signs and restarted coturn. I'll report back if that changes anything. If it doesn't work on connected users, sometimes it helps to retry a couple of times (exiting the room and reentering). We also found out that recent versions of firefox seem to work better. There seem to be error messages in the browser console if it does't work. I will try to track them down and report back. In the meantime I'll follow Maxim's advice to install the last snapshot. It's good to know that it works on other machines! -- Orm
Re: inconsistencies between browsers/OSs
Hi, it could be a problem of UDP ports. Can you check whether UDP ports are open or close in your firewall? Regards, Yarema On Thu, Apr 2, 2020 at 9:10 PM Orm Finnendahl wrote: > > Hi, > > finally our OM server is working with https behind the firewall and > NAT, ldap ist working too and we were able to succefully establish a > stable conference between two linux boxes running firefox with > audio/video (yey!). > > om is really amazing work, thanks to everyone, who contributed! > > Unfortunately we get varying success regarding audio/video with other > OS/browser combinations: On OSX it seems to work with firefox but with > Safari audio/video works locally, but the remote linux user is > invisible/inaudible for the OSX user. With other OSX users and on a > Windows/Firefox <-> Linux/Firefox combination, video and audio of the > other side isn't working on both machines, etc... > > Is this a known issue? I searched the ML archives and the Web and > couldn't find relevant information. Are there any recommendations how > to troubleshoot the problems? > > It seems quite inconsistent and I don't know yet whether it's a setup > problem on the user's/administrator's side. All participants of two > part conferences state that they see their own audio/video and see the > empty video frame of the other participant whitout hearing anything > although seeing the green button of the other participant flash. > > We are using 5.0.0-M3, Revision b739f87 > > -- > Orm
inconsistencies between browsers/OSs
Hi, finally our OM server is working with https behind the firewall and NAT, ldap ist working too and we were able to succefully establish a stable conference between two linux boxes running firefox with audio/video (yey!). om is really amazing work, thanks to everyone, who contributed! Unfortunately we get varying success regarding audio/video with other OS/browser combinations: On OSX it seems to work with firefox but with Safari audio/video works locally, but the remote linux user is invisible/inaudible for the OSX user. With other OSX users and on a Windows/Firefox <-> Linux/Firefox combination, video and audio of the other side isn't working on both machines, etc... Is this a known issue? I searched the ML archives and the Web and couldn't find relevant information. Are there any recommendations how to troubleshoot the problems? It seems quite inconsistent and I don't know yet whether it's a setup problem on the user's/administrator's side. All participants of two part conferences state that they see their own audio/video and see the empty video frame of the other participant whitout hearing anything although seeing the green button of the other participant flash. We are using 5.0.0-M3, Revision b739f87 -- Orm