Re: userCertficate;binary problem (was : Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException)
On Wed, Oct 19, 2011 at 3:45 PM, Harakiri harakiri...@yahoo.com wrote: --- On Tue, 10/18/11, Emmanuel Lécharny elecha...@apache.org wrote: From: Emmanuel Lécharny elecha...@apache.org query for this attribute - userCertificate;binary is also returned? (The previous hack would make it so, that if userCertificate;binary was requested, just userCertificate was returned - which did not help the cause because RFC states that userCertificate;binary must be returned. Yes, sadly, the ';binary' is not stored. Now, the ';binary' is optional, and can somehow being ignored. Alright, i tested the patch - it works fine - i also verified it with Thunderbird - it can now finally use the userCertificate;binary attribute. On a related note - is there an ETA for an official 2.0 release? Additionally - im getting alot of ERR info messages with just using the system default partition: 2011-10-19 14:05:01,484 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-transportId while building cross-references for the ads-repl ProvPort AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,485 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads -saslMechHandlers AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,486 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-partitions AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,486 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-transportAddress while building cross-references for the ads-replProvHostName AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,488 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-journal AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,493 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-servers AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,493 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-indexes AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,493 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-changeLog AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,495 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-interceptors AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,495 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-httpWebApps AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,496 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-transports AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,497 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-extendedOpHandlers AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:01,498 main INFO AttributeType| ERR_04303 Cannot find the SUPERIOR object ads-compositeElement while building cross-references for the ads-replConsumers AttributeType. 2011-10-19 14:05:02,806 main INFO AbstractValue| ERR_04447_CANNOT_NORMALIZE_VALUE Cannot normalize the wrapped value ERR_04226 I do not know how to handle NameAndOptionalUID normalization with objects of class: automountInformation 2011-10-19 14:05:04,473 main INFO AbstractValue| ERR_04447_CANNOT_NORMALIZE_VALUE Cannot normalize the wrapped value ERR_04226 I do not know how to handle NameAndOptionalUID normalization with objects of class: sambaSID 2011-10-19 14:05:04,474 main INFO AbstractValue| ERR_04447_CANNOT_NORMALIZE_VALUE Cannot normalize the wrapped value ERR_04226 I do not know how to handle NameAndOptionalUID normalization with objects of class: sambaLMPassword 2011-10-19 14:05:04,476 main INFO AbstractValue| ERR_04447_CANNOT_NORMALIZE_VALUE Cannot normalize the wrapped value ERR_04226 I do not know how to handle NameAndOptionalUID normalization with objects of class: sambaNTPassword 2011-10-19 14:05:04,477 main INFO AbstractValue| ERR_04447_CANNOT_NORMALIZE_VALUE Cannot normalize the wrapped value ERR_04226 I do not know how to handle NameAndOptionalUID normalization with objects of class: sambaPwdLastSet 2011-10-19 14:05:04,477 main INFO AbstractValue| ERR_04447_CANNOT_NORMALIZE_VALUE Cannot normalize the wrapped value ERR_04226 I do not know how to handle NameAndOptionalUID normalization with objects of class: sambaLogonTime 2011-10-19 14:05:04,477 main INFO AbstractValue| ERR_04447_CANNOT_NORMALIZE_VALUE Cannot normalize the wrapped value ERR_04226 I do not know how to handle NameAndOptionalUID normalization with objects of class: sambaLogoffTime 2011-10-19 14:05:04,477 main INFO AbstractValue|
Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException
--- On Sat, 10/15/11, Emmanuel Lécharny elecha...@apache.org wrote: I think you dont understand - your own code is calling IntegerOrderingComparator but it doesnt exist! i dont call it - i only call loadAllEnabled - the jar references a class which does not exist in the jar! Oops, sorry, yes, I misunderstood... However, I did a grep -R 'IntegerOrderingComparator' . on the server code (rev 2.0.0-M3) and it brings back nothing, which means this method is not present in the code base. Can you do the same thing on your computer, and give us the result ? I'd like to know which ldif file contain this class name. IMO, as Alex said, it's very likely that you are still using an old ldif file which was coming from an old version. Alright - i did not know that the auto generated schema from a previous version is doing some reflection and needs to be deleted - after that and some more porting i got my custom partition running. However - the whole point of this exercise was to be finally able to use binary attributes while answering search requests - according to the JIRA this bug should be fixed: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/DIRSERVER-1198 When i try to set this attribute however i get an exception: Error while adding values into the 'userCertificate;binary' attribute. Error : ERR_04269 ATTRIBUTE_TYPE for OID usercertificate;binary does not exist! java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: ERR_04464 Error while adding values into the 'userCertificate;binary' attribute. Error : ERR_04269 ATTRIBUTE_TYPE for O ID usercertificate;binary does not exist! at org.apache.directory.shared.ldap.model.entry.DefaultEntry.put(DefaultEntry.java:1398) code used: Entry serverEntry = new DefaultEntry(schemaManager, dn); serverEntry.put(SchemaConstants.OBJECT_CLASS_AT, SchemaConstants.INET_ORG_PERSON_OC); serverEntry.put(name, cn); ... serverEntry.put(userCertificate;binary, byte..); I gathered - that i somehow must add the oid for userCertificate;binary but im unsure how to do that... This is just readonly inmemory custom partition which should return dynamic data depending on the search request. Thank you
Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException
--- On Tue, 10/18/11, Emmanuel Lécharny elecha...@apache.org wrote: Can you test the same code without the ;binary ? serverEntry.put(userCertificate, byte..); I'm sure that we should support the ';binary' in entries, and I'm positive that is a bug. Can you please fill a JIRA, so that we don't forget to fix it ? Many thanks ! The code works fine without the binary - but im a bit confused now - the whole point of the JIRA entry was to add support for binary attributes - why do you want to open another? This issue should just be reopened: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/DIRSERVER-1198 (I can add a new entry but i dont see the point) Thanks
Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException
On 10/18/11 5:46 PM, Harakiri wrote: --- On Tue, 10/18/11, Emmanuel Lécharnyelecha...@apache.org wrote: Can you test the same code without the ;binary ? serverEntry.put(userCertificate, byte..); I'm sure that we should support the ';binary' in entries, and I'm positive that is a bug. Can you please fill a JIRA, so that we don't forget to fix it ? Many thanks ! The code works fine without the binary - but im a bit confused now - the whole point of the JIRA entry was to add support for binary attributes - why do you want to open another? This issue should just be reopened: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/DIRSERVER-1198 (I can add a new entry but i dont see the point) Ah, yes, sure. But can you add the exact reason why its failing ? It seems to be a different failure : we are trying to look for 'usercertificate;binary' in the schema on the client side, and obviously, t's not working. Doing the same thing in the server is handled correctly (well, it's a disgusting hack, frankly :/). In any case, it should be fixed... Thanks for the feedback, and sorry for the pain ... -- Regards, Cordialement, Emmanuel Lécharny www.iktek.com
userCertficate;binary problem (was : Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException)
Ok,
I have fixed the client-side code and now the following code works fine :
/**
* Test method for userCertificate;binary AT
*/
@Test
public void testUserCertificateBinary() throws LdapException
{
Entry entry = new DefaultEntry( schemaManager );
entry.add( objectClass, top, person, inetorgPerson );
entry.add( cn, test1, test2 );
entry.add( sn, Test1, Test2 );
entry.add( userPassword, BYTES1, BYTES2 );
entry.add( userCertificate;binary, Strings.getBytesUtf8(
secret ) );
assertTrue( entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate;binary ) );
assertTrue( entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate ) );
entry.removeAttributes( userCertificate;binary );
assertFalse( entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate;binary ) );
assertFalse( entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate ) );
entry.add( userCertificate, Strings.getBytesUtf8( secret ) );
assertTrue( entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate;binary ) );
assertTrue( entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate ) );
}
As you can see, there is no more difference between 'userCertificate'
and 'userCertificate;binary'.
I'm running global tests to see if it has an impact on the client or the
server, and if not, i'm going to commit the fix.
--
Regards,
Cordialement,
Emmanuel Lécharny
www.iktek.com
Re: userCertficate;binary problem (was : Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException)
--- On Tue, 10/18/11, Emmanuel Lecharny elecha...@gmail.com wrote:
From: Emmanuel Lecharny elecha...@gmail.com
Subject: userCertficate;binary problem (was : Re: Upgrading to
apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException)
To: users@directory.apache.org
Date: Tuesday, October 18, 2011, 12:26 PM
Ok,
I have fixed the client-side code and now the following
code works fine :
/**
* Test method for
userCertificate;binary AT
*/
@Test
public void testUserCertificateBinary()
throws LdapException
{
Entry entry = new DefaultEntry(
schemaManager );
entry.add( objectClass,
top, person, inetorgPerson );
entry.add( cn, test1,
test2 );
entry.add( sn, Test1,
Test2 );
entry.add( userPassword,
BYTES1, BYTES2 );
entry.add(
userCertificate;binary, Strings.getBytesUtf8( secret )
);
assertTrue(
entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate;binary ) );
assertTrue(
entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate ) );
entry.removeAttributes(
userCertificate;binary );
assertFalse(
entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate;binary ) );
assertFalse(
entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate ) );
entry.add( userCertificate,
Strings.getBytesUtf8( secret ) );
assertTrue(
entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate;binary ) );
assertTrue(
entry.containsAttribute( userCertificate ) );
}
As you can see, there is no more difference between
'userCertificate' and 'userCertificate;binary'.
I'm running global tests to see if it has an impact on the
client or the server, and if not, i'm going to commit the
fix.
Great job - thank you very much!
Is there a nightly build (complete all-in-one jar) for this available sometime
so i can test it?
I gather that when i now query for this attribute - userCertificate;binary is
also returned? (The previous hack would make it so, that if
userCertificate;binary was requested, just userCertificate was returned -
which did not help the cause because RFC states that userCertificate;binary
must be returned.
Thanks
Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException
On 10/15/11 2:06 AM, Harakiri wrote: --- On Fri, 10/14/11, Emmanuel Lecharnyelecha...@gmail.com wrote: From: Emmanuel Lecharnyelecha...@gmail.com Subject: Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException To: users@directory.apache.org Date: Friday, October 14, 2011, 9:06 AM On 10/14/11 2:43 PM, Harakiri wrote: Hello, im trying to port my custom partition from 1.5.x to 2.0.0-M3. Im getting a ClassNotFoundException when using schemaManager.loadAllEnabled(); lang.ClassNotFoundException: org.apache.directory.shared.ldap.schema.comparators.IntegerOrderingComparator I think we have removed this (useless) class. Use the IndexComparator instead; The rational is that when comparing integers, there is no need of two function, one to compare if the integers are equal, and an other one to tell if an integer is lower or higher than another one : this can be done by one single class, returning -1, 0 or 1 depending on the integers. I think you dont understand - your own code is calling IntegerOrderingComparator but it doesnt exist! i dont call it - i only call loadAllEnabled - the jar references a class which does not exist in the jar! Oops, sorry, yes, I misunderstood... However, I did a grep -R 'IntegerOrderingComparator' . on the server code (rev 2.0.0-M3) and it brings back nothing, which means this method is not present in the code base. Can you do the same thing on your computer, and give us the result ? I'd like to know which ldif file contain this class name. IMO, as Alex said, it's very likely that you are still using an old ldif file which was coming from an old version. -- Regards, Cordialement, Emmanuel Lécharny www.iktek.com
Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException
On Fri, Oct 14, 2011 at 3:43 PM, Harakiri harakiri...@yahoo.com wrote:
Hello,
im trying to port my custom partition from 1.5.x to 2.0.0-M3.
Im getting a ClassNotFoundException when using
schemaManager.loadAllEnabled();
lang.ClassNotFoundException:
org.apache.directory.shared.ldap.schema.comparators.IntegerOrderingComparator
This class isnt in the jar, infact there is no packet comperators or even
schema in the jar at all.
Additionally - im trying to port this code:
private void initSchemaPartition()
throws Exception {
SchemaPartition schemaPartition =
service.getSchemaService().getSchemaPartition();
// Init the LdifPartition
LdifPartition ldifPartition = new LdifPartition();
String workingDirectory =
service.getWorkingDirectory().getPath();
ldifPartition.setWorkingDirectory(workingDirectory + /schema);
// Extract the schema on disk (a brand new one) and load the
registries
File schemaRepository = new File(workingDirectory, schema);
SchemaLdifExtractor extractor =
new DefaultSchemaLdifExtractor(new File(workingDirectory));
extractor.extractOrCopy(true);
schemaPartition.setWrappedPartition(ldifPartition);
SchemaLoader loader= new
LdifSchemaLoader(schemaRepository);
SchemaManager schemaManager = new DefaultSchemaManager(loader);
service.setSchemaManager(schemaManager);
// We have to load the schema now, otherwise we won't be able
// to initialize the Partitions, as we won't be able to parse
// and normalize their suffix DN
schemaManager.loadAllEnabled();
schemaPartition.setSchemaManager(schemaManager);
ListThrowable errors = schemaManager.getErrors();
if (errors.size() != 0) {
throw new Exception(Schema load failed : + errors);
}
}
i got as far as this but im not sure if this is correct (because of the
class not found exception) :
private void initSchemaPartition()
throws Exception {
String workingDir= workingDirectory.getPath();
// Extract the schema on disk (a brand new one) and load the
registries
File schemaRepository = new File(workingDir, schema);
SchemaLdifExtractor extractor =
new DefaultSchemaLdifExtractor(new File(workingDir));
extractor.extractOrCopy(true);
SchemaLoader loader= new
LdifSchemaLoader(schemaRepository);
SchemaManager schemaManager = new DefaultSchemaManager(loader);
// Init the LdifPartition
LdifPartition ldifPartition = new LdifPartition(schemaManager);
service.setSchemaManager(schemaManager);
schemaManager.loadAllEnabled();
ListThrowable errors = schemaManager.getErrors();
if (errors.size() != 0) {
throw new Exception(Schema load failed : + errors);
}
}
Thanks for your assistance!
There are several references to fully qualified class names in the schema
partition which will cause problems for you when moving from the old version
to the latest release. This is due to class renaming, deletions, and package
movement.
I recommend you export an LDIF of your DIT and reimport it on the latest
release. This is the least painful most well defined path you can follow for
an upgrade at this present time.
--
Best Regards,
-- Alex
Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException
--- On Fri, 10/14/11, Emmanuel Lecharny elecha...@gmail.com wrote: From: Emmanuel Lecharny elecha...@gmail.com Subject: Re: Upgrading to apacheds-service-2.0.0-M3.jar - ClassNotFoundException To: users@directory.apache.org Date: Friday, October 14, 2011, 9:06 AM On 10/14/11 2:43 PM, Harakiri wrote: Hello, im trying to port my custom partition from 1.5.x to 2.0.0-M3. Im getting a ClassNotFoundException when using schemaManager.loadAllEnabled(); lang.ClassNotFoundException: org.apache.directory.shared.ldap.schema.comparators.IntegerOrderingComparator I think we have removed this (useless) class. Use the IndexComparator instead; The rational is that when comparing integers, there is no need of two function, one to compare if the integers are equal, and an other one to tell if an integer is lower or higher than another one : this can be done by one single class, returning -1, 0 or 1 depending on the integers. I think you dont understand - your own code is calling IntegerOrderingComparator but it doesnt exist! i dont call it - i only call loadAllEnabled - the jar references a class which does not exist in the jar!
