Re: [OMPI users] EXTERNAL: Re: What's the status of OpenMPI and thread safety?

2013-12-20 Thread Ralph Castain
Hi Ed FWIW: Intel MPI has better thread support, though you'll lose some features. I don't know what NICs you have, but have you tried running with the MTL's instead of the openib BTL? Both the psm and mxm MTLs are supposed to be thread safe, and will outperform the openib BTL anyway. Not

Re: [OMPI users] EXTERNAL: Re: What's the status of OpenMPI and thread safety?

2013-12-19 Thread Blosch, Edwin L
Thanks Ralph, We are attempting to use 1.6.4 with an application that requires multi-threading, and it is hanging most of the time; it is using openib. They steered us to try Intel MPI for now. If you lack drivers/testers for improved thread safety on openib, let me know and I'll encourage

Re: [OMPI users] [EXTERNAL] Re: What's the status of OpenMPI and thread safety?

2013-12-19 Thread Barrett, Brian W
Pablo - As Ralph mentioned, it will be different, possibly not for the better, in 1.7. This is an area of active work, so any help would be appreciated. However, the one issue you brought up is going to be problematic, even with threads. Our design essentially makes it such that blocking MPI