Re: [QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2022-12-29 Thread Jessica Johnson
Hello all, I wanted to give a very late thank you for the responses to my question (from last year!). I never received them in my own email for some reason but only came across the responses yesterday in a google search. Thank you all for your detailed suggestions. They are very much appreciate

Re: [QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2021-03-31 Thread Lorenzo Paulatto
Yes, when anharmonicity get stronger, the perturbative approach of d3q eventually breaks down. It is always possible to use stochastic (sscha) or molecular dynamics methods. Each method has trade-offs, in terms of: computational cost, ability to cope with strong anharmonicity, treatment of quan

Re: [QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2021-03-30 Thread Terry Frankcombe
While we are talking about interesting ways to include anharmonic effects, it's worth taking a look at SSCHA: http://sscha.eu/ Not necessarily computationally inexpensive. On Wed, 2021-03-31 at 07:20 +0900, Kazume NISHIDATE wrote: > > 2021/03/31 1:00、Lorenzo Paulatto のメール: > > > > Hello you can

Re: [QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2021-03-30 Thread Kazume NISHIDATE
> 2021/03/31 1:00、Lorenzo Paulatto のメール: > > Hello you can take into account anharmonicity with the d3q code which is > included in QE, This may be the most sophisticated way to account for the anharmonicity from first principle. I'm impress by the ingeniousness. Thank you for your notice. b

Re: [QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2021-03-30 Thread Lorenzo Paulatto
Hello you can take into account anharmonicity with the d3q code which is included in QE, but also has its own homepage at https://anharmonic.github.io/ where you may find more documentation and examples. In particular, I recently added an example on how to compute the vibrational spectral weight

Re: [QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2021-03-30 Thread Kazume NISHIDATE
Hi, Jessica > 2021/03/30 1:53、Jessica Johnson のメール: > > I have a very general question about Raman calculations (I will include that > I am using QE version 6.4.1 per the posting guidelines in case that helps my > answer my question). The derivatives of the potential give the T^2 and T^3 dep

Re: [QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2021-03-30 Thread Paolo Giannozzi
On Mon, Mar 29, 2021 at 6:54 PM Jessica Johnson wrote: I understood that anharmonicity is taken into account with the inclusion of > second and third order energy derivatives. > anharmonicity "may" be taken into account with the inclusion of second and third order energy derivatives, but in ord

[QE-users] ph.x Raman calculations

2021-03-29 Thread Jessica Johnson
Hello QE world, I have a very general question about Raman calculations (I will include that I am using QE version 6.4.1 per the posting guidelines in case that helps my answer my question). Background: I am calculating Raman shifts in strained 2D MoS2 polymorphs. It was mentioned to me to by