Re: [videoblogging] Re: Copyrights and the artist's right to control their work

2006-01-19 Thread David Meade
On 1/19/06, Pete Prodoehl <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > There is one difference though, NBC and Comedy Central have lawyers, > lots of lawyers... well that doesn't make their use more just ... it only means they have greater means to prove they are are just in their use. :-) (but I know what you

Re: [videoblogging] Re: Copyrights and the artist's right to control their work

2006-01-19 Thread Pete Prodoehl
gmjoyce_y wrote: > Very good post, Richard. Nicely balanced. > > I know you're not a lawyer but can you (or anyone else who wants to > take a crack at it) tell me if I've got this right? > > Saturday Night Live or The Daily Show can show clips from TV shows > because they're commending on or

Re: [videoblogging] Re: Copyrights and the artist's right to control their work

2006-01-18 Thread Arnþór Snær
Yes i think fair use in the "public performance" scenario depends on the usage of the work being to comment on the work (including news & reviews) & educate on a aspect of the work or on it as a whole. So, while it may not be okay for me to use the latest top40 single for my vlog theme song, it wo

[videoblogging] Re: Copyrights and the artist's right to control their work

2006-01-18 Thread Ms. Kitka
> Saturday Night Live or The Daily Show can show clips from TV shows > because they're commending on or parodying the content of those clips. > So comment or satire makes these copyrighted clips fair game, is that > right? > > And if SNL and Jon Stewart can do it, can't vloggers do likewise? Q

[videoblogging] Re: Copyrights and the artist's right to control their work

2006-01-18 Thread gmjoyce_y
Very good post, Richard. Nicely balanced. I know you're not a lawyer but can you (or anyone else who wants to take a crack at it) tell me if I've got this right? Saturday Night Live or The Daily Show can show clips from TV shows because they're commending on or parodying the content of those

[videoblogging] Re: Copyrights and the artist's right to control their work

2006-01-18 Thread Ms. Kitka
--- In videoblogging@yahoogroups.com, Richard BF <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I'm also not a lawyer, just to get that out there, but my girlfriend > is, and I've been involved with and negotiated copyright and the use > of music in the past. > > Andreas pointed to other posts on the legalities