Re: [Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds

2012-02-16 Thread Susan Weber
Nadia: Somebody gave you incorrect advice. You apply the law of the country where you will be using the item, not the law where you buy from. As Jessica just said, we, in Canada, wish it were the other way around, but because it isn't, we have to pay millions of dollars extra (nationally) for

Re: [Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds

2012-02-16 Thread Jessica Rosner
FYI Nadia copyright law is one thing, dealing with the French is another. There may be cultural/political reasons a French library in particular would want to keep in their good graces. I suspect a librarian at semi- official French Library you may be obliged by circumstance to "accept" French cop

Re: [Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds

2012-02-16 Thread Jessica Rosner
At the risk of ruining my reputation as an evil rights holder trying to suppress educational use, the French librarian is wrong. In the US, US copyright law applies. France and much of Europe for instance have copyright terms far longer than the US but that does not apply here, When the first Melie

Re: [Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds

2012-02-16 Thread Nadia Gabriel
Hi all, I did mean Region TWO dvds, in this case, published in France, sorry!! What I've heard so far from librarians in France and in the US is that we apply the law of the country we're buying from: There is no "Doctrine of First Sale" in France - librarians pay an extra fee for each DVD they p

Re: [Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds

2012-02-16 Thread Shoaf,Judith P
rkeley.edu] On Behalf Of Nadia Gabriel Sent: Wednesday, February 15, 2012 9:00 PM To: videolib@lists.berkeley.edu Subject: [Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds Hi all, I'm interrupting this conversation to bounce on Brigid's answer Found this through a Fren

Re: [Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds

2012-02-15 Thread Jessica Rosner
This is a contract issue not a copyright issue. While it is a bit of grey area, It is pretty clear if you buy a legal copy and DO NOT transfer the format you can use it. It is pretty much the same as buying a book in a foreign language. Any legal issue is between the seller and the copyright holder

[Videolib] (was) Looking for The Red and the Black - region 1 dvds

2012-02-15 Thread Nadia Gabriel
Hi all, I'm interrupting this conversation to bounce on Brigid's answer Found this through a French site, but it is a Region 1 DVD sold by amazon.com: [...] How often do you purchase Region 1 DVDs for your library? If/when you do, should you pay a copyright fee, or what they call "droit de prĂȘt"