"guitar enthusiasts".That is not what I wrote. I have no opinion on
the Summit List, but the Lake Konstanz meeting is attended by serious
scholars, playersA and publishers as well as the usual assortment of
kooks.
A
Jelma
On Wed, Jun 25, 2014 at 8:08 AM, Monica Hall <[1]
Well yes... though if papers are presented, but not disseminated by
the 'Summit' and/or are not peer reviewed is there not the problem
(alas too common) of mere speculation being transformed into generally
accepted fact?
Martyn
___
I don't know, Martyn. Generally, any paper being presented at any
conference or festival does not turn into generally accepted fact, does
it? If there is such a thing as 'fact' in historical research :-)
A
I certainly attend these things with a healthy dose of scepticism.
Howeve
As I understand it, the (9!) guitar related articles in Early Music 41/4 and
42/1 were all reviewed by outside readers.
-Oorspronkelijk bericht-
Van: lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu [mailto:lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu] Namens
Martyn Hodgson
Verzonden: woensdag 25 juni 2014 10:59
Aan: Monica Hall
Indeed . But I'm referring to the many other papers presented at the
'Summits' which, I'm told, are not usually published or otherwise made
generally available.
__
From: Lex Eisenhardt
To: Vihuelalist
Sent: W
Thanks for this Jelma,
However I really didn't suggest that ANY paper presented at the
'Summit' would always automatically transform speculation (or even mere
personal assertion) into generally accepted fact, but that some
speculation/assertion presented in the past has, indeed, been
What would you do about it? No more talks at Lute or Guitar meetings, unless
approved by the musicological authorities?
-Oorspronkelijk bericht-
Van: lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu [mailto:lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu] Namens
Martyn Hodgson
Verzonden: woensdag 25 juni 2014 15:27
Aan: Jelma van A
Thanks for this Lex.
I thought I'd said: if a paper is presented at a conference, thus
giving it something of an aura of authority, then if not peer
appraised/reviewed (which isn't always possible or practicable) it
ought to be made generally available. Preferably in full or at least
