Re: Vimdiff Oddity
On Fri 8-Sep-06 4:11pm -0600, Bram Moolenaar wrote: Bill McCarthy wrote: To better understand what vimdiff is doing (and why it is so slow), I had my shell (4NT under WinXP) keep a log showing me just what was requested. [Note: I use '!' instead of '' for redirection because my 4NT is set to not overwrite existing files unless explicitly told to do so.] Invoking vimdiff with: gvim -d file1 file2 I can see that the following 3 shell requests are made: diff -a VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp The log shows about 4 seconds between commands. I would have thought that the first diff would provide enough information. What is the purpose of the other two? Vim first tests to see if executing diff works, with the -a and --binary arguments. Finally it does the actual diff. This should take a fraction of a second. 4 seconds indicates that there is something wrong in your setup. Perhaps caused by 4NT. Try using another shell. Thank you for your comments. I had added using Windows volatile environment variables supported by 4nt. The author (Rex Conn of JPSoft) simply uses an API call to implement these. They are deadly slow and account for nearly all of the time delay. 4nt, without that baggage, is still a fraction of a second slower that cmd (which itself is about the same startup speed of sh or zsh). I am curious about the necessity of those 3 shell calls to do a diff - maybe I'll spend a little time with diff.c next weekend :-) -- Best regards, Bill
Re: Vimdiff Oddity
Bill McCarthy wrote: To better understand what vimdiff is doing (and why it is so slow), I had my shell (4NT under WinXP) keep a log showing me just what was requested. [Note: I use '!' instead of '' for redirection because my 4NT is set to not overwrite existing files unless explicitly told to do so.] Invoking vimdiff with: gvim -d file1 file2 I can see that the following 3 shell requests are made: diff -a VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp The log shows about 4 seconds between commands. I would have thought that the first diff would provide enough information. What is the purpose of the other two? Vim first tests to see if executing diff works, with the -a and --binary arguments. Finally it does the actual diff. This should take a fraction of a second. 4 seconds indicates that there is something wrong in your setup. Perhaps caused by 4NT. Try using another shell. -- ARTHUR: Bloody peasant! DENNIS: Oh, what a give away. Did you here that, did you here that, eh? That's what I'm on about -- did you see him repressing me, you saw it didn't you? The Quest for the Holy Grail (Monty Python) /// Bram Moolenaar -- [EMAIL PROTECTED] -- http://www.Moolenaar.net \\\ ///sponsor Vim, vote for features -- http://www.Vim.org/sponsor/ \\\ \\\download, build and distribute -- http://www.A-A-P.org/// \\\help me help AIDS victims -- http://ICCF-Holland.org///
Vimdiff Oddity
Hello Vim Developers, To better understand what vimdiff is doing (and why it is so slow), I had my shell (4NT under WinXP) keep a log showing me just what was requested. [Note: I use '!' instead of '' for redirection because my 4NT is set to not overwrite existing files unless explicitly told to do so.] Invoking vimdiff with: gvim -d file1 file2 I can see that the following 3 shell requests are made: diff -a VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp The log shows about 4 seconds between commands. I would have thought that the first diff would provide enough information. What is the purpose of the other two? -- Best regards, Bill
Re: Vimdiff Oddity
Bill McCarthy wrote: Hello Vim Developers, To better understand what vimdiff is doing (and why it is so slow), I had my shell (4NT under WinXP) keep a log showing me just what was requested. [Note: I use '!' instead of '' for redirection because my 4NT is set to not overwrite existing files unless explicitly told to do so.] Invoking vimdiff with: gvim -d file1 file2 I can see that the following 3 shell requests are made: diff -a VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp diff -a --binary VIo2A3F.tmp VIn2A40.tmp !VId2A41.tmp The log shows about 4 seconds between commands. I would have thought that the first diff would provide enough information. What is the purpose of the other two? Just guessing. As noted in the help (e.g. under :help 'diffexpr'), vimdiff uses ed-style diffs, which (unlike context or unified diffs) are not reversible. It may need those three calls to properly highlight both windows of the vimdiff. The fact that the temporary files' _names_ are the same between calls doesn't prove that their _contents_ are the same. Or you may have a nonstandard diff.exe: the --help for my GNU diff (version 2.8.7) makes no mention of a --binary argument. Best regards, Tony.
