Re: [Wien] incorrect band splitting when RLO added for a system with spatial inversion

2016-12-21 Thread Peter Blaha
Emax seems converged. This is no issue. Yes, from my point of view the "best" calculation should be to put 5p in core (+ .locre if necessary) and have the 6p RLO. It seems it has a rather large effect. To check my results I would: a) Calculate the qtl's with p-1/2 p3/2 splitting (x qtl -so)

Re: [Wien] incorrect band splitting when RLO added for a system with spatial inversion

2016-12-21 Thread Martin Gmitra
Thanks for replay! Considering the RLO for 6P (0.3 Ry), it strengthen the spin-orbit coupling effects rather significantly, comparable to results when considering RLO for 5P at -8Ry, see yellow and dark red curves in the attached plot. Can one understand this as the orthogonality effect as you

Re: [Wien] incorrect band splitting when RLO added for a system with spatial inversion

2016-12-15 Thread Peter Blaha
Is this all converged with respect to EMAX in case.in1 ??? So from your figure one would find that these bands at EF are affected by >0.1 eV when you add a p1/2 basis function at -8 Ry This sounds VERY strange to me and I don't know if one can explain this by an "orthogonality effect"

Re: [Wien] incorrect band splitting when RLO added for a system with spatial inversion

2016-12-15 Thread Martin Gmitra
Dear Peter, Thank you for your answer. The main reason to use the RLO is the effect close to the Fermi level, where the top valence and bottom conduction bands are strongly pushed towards each other due to spin-orbit coupling. In the attached figure you can find plot for the different cases.

Re: [Wien] incorrect band splitting when RLO added for a system with spatial inversion

2016-12-14 Thread Peter Blaha
This is related to the fact, that the RLOs are implemented without symmetry constrains (and relativistic spherical harmonics basis) and for numerical reasons this leads to these small splittings. This is also noted when calculating EFGs, that one must not use RLOs. Why are you using RLOs and

[Wien] incorrect band splitting when RLO added for a system with spatial inversion

2016-12-13 Thread Martin Gmitra
Dear Wien2k users, I am facing a problem with symmetry preserved result when relativistic local orbital (RLO) is added to the spin-orbit coupling calculations. The system is bismuthene, a 2D layer of Bi atoms, in orthorombic lattice WITH inversion. Without RLO the bands are doubly degenerated,