Re: [Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-04-03 Thread Lodewijk
Hey Edward, sorry for the delay in responding - I was a bit overflowing with stuff that needed to happen irl. Sorry to see too that there were so few other responses at all to my questions for input (two on the talk page). In some way, my proposal is an experiment of course. This isn't meant as

Re: [Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-04-03 Thread Andrew Lih
Hi Lodewijk, I like the idea of discussions that are more structured and well-known before the conference. Re: Taiwan, which open space idea were you describing that didn't work? Was that the lightning talks or something else? -Andrew Lih Associate professor of journalism, American University

Re: [Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-04-03 Thread Lodewijk
I was referring to the 'open space' where there was a space (which also happened to be really open, near the registration desk) where the schedule was very fluid (if memory serves me well) and where people were asked to just stand up and start talking. Not lightning (I like those, if well

Re: [Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-04-03 Thread Alice Wiegand
I understand Lodewijk's idea as an option to include more substance discussions as a kind of addition to the speaker/audience situation we have in most sessions. And that should be worth thinking about. The larger the conference becomes the harder it is to find session formats that are different

[Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-03-26 Thread Lodewijk
Hi, with the submission deadline approaching, I wasn't able to find many discussion proposals (not counting panel discussions) where the audience is the main participant, and there is no particular speaker or expert. In a wiki-conference, that is always a surprise to me. I recall from past years

Re: [Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-03-26 Thread Edward Saperia
The programme submissions process we're using is one that we inherited from previous Wikimanias, but given that this event is not considered a formal, research-led event, and also frankly the rate of change of the world, having people submit sessions six months in advance seems surprising.

Re: [Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-03-26 Thread Lodewijk
Hi Edward, not entirely, but it would be a step in the right direction. I'm volunteering to help run that process and lead the discussions on the day itself (if certain conditions can be fulfilled, which I dont expect to be a problem). But also, I'm suggesting to turn the process around a bit. If

Re: [Wikimania-l] Discussion Room - would like more input

2014-03-26 Thread Edward Saperia
I am told that, historically, there's a massive rush of submissions in the last day or two. Let's wait and see what the quality of the submissions is like, we may be surprised. I am keen to innovate in programming with this event; an unconference track is a nod towards this, but there may be