Re: [Wikimania-l] Fwd: Wikimania Scholarship

2015-08-01 Thread Pine W
Since there seems to be considerable community interest in how Wikimania scholarships are awarded, could a review of the scholarship selection process, and the splits of how funds are allocated (partial or full, GS or GN) be included in the scope of the upcoming community consultation about

Re: [Wikimania-l] Wikimania Scholarship

2015-08-01 Thread Zana Strkovska
Just some thoughts over this sentence: *The ability to share experiences and information with a wider community indicates that the applicant, if awarded a scholarship, would be able to bring those experiences or lessons learned at Wikimania back home, thereby enriching their home wiki community or

Re: [Wikimania-l] Wikimania Scholarship

2015-08-01 Thread Amir Ladsgroup
(It got in moderation because of big size, I deleted everything) Not Correct. When a regular attendee goes a Wikimania, he or she knows better about the environment, can make better connection and work more efficiently. I (as a regular attendee) reported to my community this year in 23 July

Re: [Wikimania-l] Wikimania Scholarship

2015-08-01 Thread Federico Leva (Nemo)
Amir Ladsgroup, 01/08/2015 14:02: helped wikimania newbies to write their applications more efficiently and helped them to prepare proper documents for visa which is super complicated That's great! We should have more Wikimania recruiters/helpers like you. Maybe they should form a Wikimania

Re: [Wikimania-l] Fwd: Wikimania Scholarship

2015-08-01 Thread Pine W
I like several of Kerry's points. I did mention to Luis at WMCON that it might be more cost-effective, and potentially higher impact for some participants, to put more emphasis on national (or thematic) conferences and less on the general Wikimania conference. Pine On Sat, Aug 1, 2015 at 8:55

Re: [Wikimania-l] Fwd: Wikimania Scholarship

2015-08-01 Thread Romaine Wiki
I also agree with the points Kerry brings in. (As I have no experience with South America, Africa or Asia, I can only speak of my experiences in Europe.) I do not think national conferences are the solution to this. For large countries it can help. Also national conferences are certainly needed.

Re: [Wikimania-l] Fwd: Wikimania Scholarship

2015-08-01 Thread Kerry Raymond
I think you put your finger on a key point here. We have a large community of “totally deserving people” but mostly get little/no recognition of their contribution. Most organisations that rely on volunteers have a range of ways to recognising their efforts. In the world of WMF, other

Re: [Wikimania-l] Wikimania Scholarship, Ellie Young's comments

2015-08-01 Thread Mina Theofilatou
Hi all and happy August:) I've been watching this discussion on Wikimania Scholarships, and I'm happy that Ellie joined in the discussion: I think her reply was the most valuable and well-referenced in the thread. Being a first-time Wikimania scholarship participant - I was offered a

[Wikimania-l] links and bounces

2015-08-01 Thread Jane Darnell
Mina, Thanks for your input, and I hope you are eventually able to work your idea into a proposal. I see that my original mail (which included the link you request) didn't make it to the list. You can still see it here in the archives from July as the last mail in the list under Thread. I don't