Re: [Wikimedia-l] Category: French Jews on en.wp / GDPR

2018-06-01 Thread Benjamin Lees
On Mon, May 28, 2018 at 9:33 AM, sashi wrote: > Given that the category French Jews contains more members than the category > French Roman Catholics, and that there are living people included in both > categories... I would again recommend caution in looking at numbers, because Category:French

Re: [Wikimedia-l] Category: French Jews on en.wp / GDPR

2018-05-31 Thread Samuel Klein
I agree with everything you say 100%. On Fri 1 Jun, 2018, 2:50 AM sashi, wrote: > Another follow-up: > > == > Benjamin Lees wrote: "No, French Christians are just tagged with > subcategories of Category:French Christians. The "requiring diffusion" > category that you complain of is in fact

[Wikimedia-l] Category: French Jews on en.wp / GDPR

2018-05-31 Thread sashi
Another follow-up: == Benjamin Lees wrote: "No, French Christians are just tagged with subcategories of Category:French Christians. The "requiring diffusion" category that you complain of is in fact a way to tell editors that pages in the category should really be in subcategories