Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Clint Ricker
Sam and Matt, very well said. To the rest: If you are petitioning the FCC in union with the cable companies and telcos, you are screwing your future and help your competition. You can't win by the rules that they make. The network neutrality battle could potentially change the service provider

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Mike Hammett
I'm glad someone else has the same philosophy I do. - Mike Hammett Intelligent Computing Solutions http://www.ics-il.com - Original Message - From: Clint Ricker [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: WISPA General List wireless@wispa.org Sent: Monday, November 19, 2007 9:48 AM Subject: Re:

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Mike Hammett
I'm glad someone else has the same philosophy I do. - Mike Hammett Intelligent Computing Solutions http://www.ics-il.com - Original Message - From: Clint Ricker [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: WISPA General List wireless@wispa.org Sent: Monday, November 19, 2007 9:48 AM Subject: Re:

Re: [WISPA] vlans

2007-11-19 Thread Clint Ricker
Travis, Are you routing or bridging between between the clients, APs, and your router? It would probably be worth doing packet captures and actually seeing what the traffic is. If you are routing between the AP and the router, then it is very unlikely that your problem is broadcast related.

[WISPA] 900 Grid Vs. Yagi

2007-11-19 Thread Luke Pack
I have a situation where interference is playing a part in degrading my signal. I am currently using flat panel 13db antennas. I want to try a yagi or grid (been looking at Pac-Wireless) to narrow the beam and hope to overcome this problem. We were fine until the leaves fell off all the

Re: [WISPA] 900 Grid Vs. Yagi

2007-11-19 Thread Luke Pack
crap, forgot to mention, I am using Canopy 900 APs. - Original Message - From: Luke Pack [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: WISPA General List wireless@wispa.org Sent: Monday, November 19, 2007 11:03 AM Subject: [WISPA] 900 Grid Vs. Yagi I have a situation where interference is playing a part in

Re: [WISPA] 900 Grid Vs. Yagi

2007-11-19 Thread Matt Liotta
We have always liked Yagis better than grids. Additionally, we prefer higher gain (tighter beamwidth) antennas with lower transmit power. Of course, with 900Mhz is can be tough to get higher gain. Besides going the parabolic route, which is problematic with 900Mhz; you can look at using loop

[WISPA] 3650 PtMP vs. 2.4 PtMP

2007-11-19 Thread Mike Hammett
Who has used 3650 in a true PtMP residential customer application? How does it really work compared to 2.4? Next year I'm putting up 2 more towers and had planned on 2.4 GHz 90* sectors. - Mike Hammett Intelligent Computing Solutions http://www.ics-il.com

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Marlon K. Schafer (509) 982-2181
That's easy to say when you are in an area with thousands of potential customers ;-) Marlon (509) 982-2181 (408) 907-6910 (Vonage)Consulting services 42846865 (icq)WISP Operator since 1999! [EMAIL PROTECTED] www.odessaoffice.com/wireless

Re: [WISPA] 3650 PtMP vs. 2.4 PtMP

2007-11-19 Thread Matt Liotta
Mike Hammett wrote: Who has used 3650 in a true PtMP residential customer application? How does it really work compared to 2.4? Next year I'm putting up 2 more towers and had planned on 2.4 GHz 90* sectors. As far as I am aware, no one has received a license in 3650 to provide service to

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread George Rogato
I'm not buying it. Yes, we as service providers have a right to determine th service level agreements we want to set for the price we decide. A consumer has always believed that they have an unlimited do anything they want with our connection mentality. We on the other hand have always had

RE: [WISPA] vlans

2007-11-19 Thread Mac Dearman
Behalf Of Russ Kreigh snip A temporary, or transitional step would be to replace the switch with a Mikrotik, connecting each AP's ethernet into it. And implement port filters to prevent ARP between ports. [Mac says] I don't think its ARP issues, but I think Russ has an excellent

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Clint Ricker
Marlon, you are pretty rural :) You probably would have a hard time growing much without heading 500 miles to find a market with more people than cows :). From what I'd guess from your economics, strict bandwidth caps may be a good choice for you--but, for people who either are in or have

Re: [WISPA] 3650 PtMP vs. 2.4 PtMP

2007-11-19 Thread Mike Hammett
People have used basically the same gear in 3650 for a couple years now thanks to experimental licenses. I know of two that have, but I have not heard their input yet on my latest inquiry. - Mike Hammett Intelligent Computing Solutions http://www.ics-il.com - Original Message -

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Mike Hammett
I've been a firm believer in that the last mile can shoot themselves in the foot if they like, but the next company up in the chain must be neutral. Level 3, ATT, Cogent, Verizon, NTT, etc. should not be doing anything on their end for their wholesale markets again, if they have retail end

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Clint Ricker
George, No one is saying that you have to sell $40 10Mb/s pipes at to customers for them to use full tilt 24x7. Restrict on bandwidth, if you choose. Sell metered. Put caps on. Why restrict based on content type? Marlon includes, if I remember, 6GB of data and then charges for overages. If

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread David E. Smith
Clint Ricker wrote: No one is saying that you have to sell $40 10Mb/s pipes at to customers for them to use full tilt 24x7. Restrict on bandwidth, if you choose. Sell metered. Put caps on. Why restrict based on content type? Because some content types make customers call and complain, and

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Anthony Will
The application is very important. If the technology that we had at our disposal would not be hampered by any application then I could care less. Your right the more bits and applications for our customers use the better for us. Unfortunately in most markets the only thing we can provide

Re: [WISPA] 3650 PtMP vs. 2.4 PtMP

2007-11-19 Thread Matt Liotta
Mike Hammett wrote: People have used basically the same gear in 3650 for a couple years now thanks to experimental licenses. I know of two that have, but I have not heard their input yet on my latest inquiry. Those of that have using experimental licenses only got to test things such as

Re: [WISPA] EarthLink Says No More Money for Existing Muni Networks

2007-11-19 Thread Tom DeReggi
I didn't say trying to partner with 500 WISPs around the country, using different products. I was referring to singling out maybe the top 20 candidates nationwide, and then helping those 20 be all they can be. There are many WISPs that could take off with jsut a bit of funding. Banks don;t

Re: [WISPA] 3650 PtMP vs. 2.4 PtMP

2007-11-19 Thread Dylan Oliver
Reading Covad's narrative rationale for their license, it sounded to me like they were offering limited commercial service on a limited, clearly-labeled-as-experimental basis: The use of limited market studies will permit equipment testing (like other markets) as well as deployment of limited

[WISPA] BumbleBee Spectrum Analyzer

2007-11-19 Thread Larry A Weidig
Has anybody used one of these with their WISP operations and care to comment on how well they work, either publicly or privately. We are looking to purchase one, but would like to make sure they work in real life situations. The two applications we would like to use them for are tracking

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Tom DeReggi
Matt, All your points are very good, and I agree with. The issue with Peer to Peer is that the entity controlling what data gets transfered is NOT the person that bought the broadband connection. Most end users aren;t savy enough to even know what impact the peer to peer software would have

Re: [WISPA] EarthLink Says No More Money for Existing Muni Networks

2007-11-19 Thread Tom DeReggi
Yes... But my approach is different. Its not to be a wholesaler or a reseller. Instead Earthlink takes teh roll of a friendly VentureCapitol Except they take it one step further... The WISP is required to Outsource Support, for large projects, to the VC's support company (Earthlink). The WISP

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread Mark Nash
Apples an oranges here. We as providers are paying for dedicated bandwidth, not shared. Shared connections are a different beast altogether, and I really would assume that's what we're talking about when we go rate-limiting ANYTHING. Dedicated connections should be able to do whatever they

[WISPA] P2P Countermeasures

2007-11-19 Thread Ron Wallace
To All, The issue of P2P rears its relatively unattractivehead in my neck of the woods from time to time. This is one of those times. - So, what is everyone doing to'counter' the influx of traffic from P2P? - What are the most effective P2P countermeasures that you have employed, lately? -

RE: [WISPA] P2P Countermeasures

2007-11-19 Thread CHUCK PROFITO
Ron, I think this will be answered readily on the members list when asked. Chuck Profito 209-988-7388 CV-ACCESS, INC [EMAIL PROTECTED] Providing High Speed Broadband to Rural Central California -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Ron

Re: [WISPA] Which UPS to use?

2007-11-19 Thread John Thomas
If you have an APC SmartUPS 750 XL, you can add APC battery packs. They even have a UXBP24 that does Battery Volt-Amp-Hour Capacity 3360 It is definitely more expensive than other batteries, but it does plug right in John Thomas Tom DeReggi wrote: You also want to use a combination of

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread George Rogato
I may be wrong, but net neutrality when out a couple of months ago. There is no more net neutrality. WISPA Wants You! Join today! http://signup.wispa.org/

Re: [WISPA] Vuze / Comcast / Peer to Peer / FCC

2007-11-19 Thread George Rogato
I'm not talking about dedicated commercial bandwidth. I'm trying to distinguish it from a consumer broadband connection. A consumer internet connection has always had restrictions. I would like to be able to offer a consumer a connection that allows P2P, and anything else they may want to do.