[WSG] tabular data

2007-03-06 Thread Bob Schwartz
I'm reworking a site to get it up to web standards. Tables should be used only to contain tabular data Would current accepted practices be: If it can be done without a table that should be first choice. or Is there a definition of what is considered tabular data (or is it in the eyes of

Re: [WSG] tabular data

2007-03-06 Thread Gunlaug Sørtun
Bob Schwartz wrote: I'm reworking a site to get it up to web standards. Tables should be used only to contain tabular data The simplest expansion of this is: - do *not* use tables to lay out a page. - use tables _within_ a page when dealing with tabular data. Would this be acceptable for

Re: [WSG] tabular data

2007-03-06 Thread Chris Price
Bob Schwartz wrote: Is there a definition of what is considered tabular data (or is it in the eyes of the beholder)? Would this be acceptable for using a table: http://www.fifeweb.org/wp/org/org_jdg_sdt_lst.html This looks like a candidate for a table but my concern would be that the table

Re: [WSG] tabular data

2007-03-06 Thread Rob Kirton
Bob Using tabular form should be the first choice; where you have what is naturally a table. What you have is clearly a table. I would suggest that if reworking this and really taking the needs of users into account; maybe breaking the data into a series of smaller tables (possibly based

Re: [WSG] tabular data

2007-03-06 Thread Bob Schwartz
Chris, Georg, Thanks for the information. Regarding the table used to construct the page and the cent table not being well constructed, etc.: those are reasons why I am redoing the site. My only concern here was to have an example of what you guys consider a candidate for tabular data

Re: [WSG] tabular data

2007-03-06 Thread Kay Smoljak
Is there a definition of what is considered tabular data (or is it in the eyes of the beholder)? If you would put it in a spreadsheet, it belongs in a table. Your example is tabular data. -- Kay Smoljak business: www.cleverstarfish.com standards: kay.zombiecoder.com coldfusion: kay.smoljak.com

RE: [WSG] tabular data

2007-03-06 Thread John Horner
to use the table's rows and columns to locate the answer by its coordinates, so to speak. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Bob Schwartz Sent: Tuesday, 6 March 2007 9:37 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] tabular data