Re: [zfs-discuss] When writing to SLOG at full speed all disk IO is blocked

2009-07-28 Thread Marcelo Leal
Ok Bob, but i think that is the problem about picket fencing... and so we are talking about commit the sync operations to disk. What i'm seeing is no read activity from disks when the slog is beeing written. The disks are zero (no read, no write). Thanks a lot for your reply. Leal [

Re: [zfs-discuss] When writing to SLOG at full speed all disk IO is blocked

2009-07-28 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Tue, 28 Jul 2009, Marcelo Leal wrote: Ok Bob, but i think that is the problem about picket fencing... and so we are talking about commit the sync operations to disk. What i'm seeing is no read activity from disks when the slog is beeing written. The disks are zero (no read, no write).

Re: [zfs-discuss] When writing to SLOG at full speed all disk IO is blocked

2009-07-28 Thread Ross
My understanding is that there's never any need for a reader to wait for a write in progress. ZFS keeps all writes in memory until they're committed to disk - if you ever try to read something that's either waiting to be, or is being written to disk, ZFS will serve it straight from RAM. One

Re: [zfs-discuss] When writing to SLOG at full speed all disk IO is blocked

2009-07-27 Thread Marcelo Leal
Hello, Well, i'm trying to understand this workload, but what i'm seeing to reproduce this is just flood the SSD with writes, and the disks show no activity. I'm testing with aggr (two links), and for one or two seconds there is no read activity (output from server). Right now i'm suspecting

Re: [zfs-discuss] When writing to SLOG at full speed all disk IO is blocked

2009-07-27 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Mon, 27 Jul 2009, Marcelo Leal wrote: Well, i'm trying to understand this workload, but what i'm seeing to reproduce this is just flood the SSD with writes, and the disks show no activity. I'm testing with aggr (two links), and for one or two seconds there is no read activity (output from

Re: [zfs-discuss] When writing to SLOG at full speed all disk IO is blocked

2009-07-26 Thread Andre Lue
byleal, Can you share how to recreate or test this? -- This message posted from opensolaris.org ___ zfs-discuss mailing list zfs-discuss@opensolaris.org http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/zfs-discuss

[zfs-discuss] When writing to SLOG at full speed all disk IO is blocked

2009-07-24 Thread Marcelo Leal
Hello all... I'm seeing this behaviour in an old build (89), and i just want to hear from you if there is some known bug about it. I'm aware of the picket fencing problem, and that ZFS is not choosing right if write to slog is better or not (thinking if we have a better throughput from disks).