Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS Mirroring - Scenario

2008-07-11 Thread Ross
Essentially yes, the entire pool dies. If you think of each mirror as an individual disk, you've just striped them together so the pool goes offline if any mirror fails, and each mirror can only guard against one half of the mirror failing. If you want to guard against any two trays failing,

Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS Mirroring - Scenario

2008-07-11 Thread Johan Hartzenberg
Sorry, but I'm stuck at 6540. There are so many options in how you would practically configure these that there is no way to give a sensible answer to your question. But the most basic questions are: Does the racks have power from separate PDUs? Are they in physically remote locations? Does

Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS Mirroring - Scenario

2008-07-11 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Fri, 11 Jul 2008, Ross wrote: If you want to guard against any two trays failing, you need to use some kind of dual parity protection. Either dual mirrors, or raid-z2. Given that you only have 8 LUN's, raid-z2 would seem to be the best option. System reliability will be dominated by

Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS Mirroring - Scenario

2008-07-11 Thread Robb Sanvely
Thank you for all the feedback! It's appreciated! @hartz Does the racks have power from separate PDUs? Yes Are they in physically remote locations? No, the racks are side by side Does your fabric switches have redundant power from separate PDUs? yes Do you want mirroring here purely for

[zfs-discuss] ZFS Mirroring - Scenario

2008-07-10 Thread Robb Snavely
I have a scenario (tray failure) that I am trying to predict how zfs will behave and am looking for some input . Coming from the world of svm, ZFS is WAY different ;) If we have 2 racks, containing 4 trays each, 2 6540's that present 8D Raid5 luns to the OS/zfs and through zfs we setup a

Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS Mirroring - Scenario

2008-07-10 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Thu, 10 Jul 2008, Robb Snavely wrote: Now in the VERY unlikely event that we lost the first tray in each rack which contain 0 and 4 respectively... somepool mirror--- 0 | 4 | Bye Bye ---