Hi again,

I tried to reproduce it by different ways, but did not succeed.

Can you please:
- share your mailetcontainer.xml configuration file
- share your smtpserver.xml configuration file
- take a capture of the smtp traffic while sending the email. Maybe your email client is doing some weird things that James does not handle yet.

Regards,
Raphaël Ouazana.

Le 2018-09-05 11:19, Raphael OUAZANA a écrit :
Hi,

Thank you for you detailed report. We'll look at reproducing it, and
open a bug if necessary.
In the mean time, can you please share your mailetcontainer.xml
configuration file?

Regards,
Raphaël Ouazana.

Le 2018-09-01 04:35, Rich P a écrit :
When I send an email to an external recipient (outside domain) and
BCC: an internal recipient (local domain), the BCC: recipient never
receives the email.  Also, if an internal recipient is in the TO:
field and an external recipient in the BCC: field, the external
recipient gets the email but the internal recipient does not.  I can
consistently reproduce this.  For example:

Scenario 1:
TO:  b...@microsoft.com<mailto:b...@microsoft.com>
BCC:  ad...@externalcompany.com<mailto:ad...@externalcompany.com>
BCC: collea...@externalcompany.com<mailto:collea...@externalcompany.com>

In this case, everyone receives their email as expected.

Scenario 2:
TO:  fri...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:fri...@mylocalhost.com>
BCC:  ad...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:ad...@mylocalhost.com>
BCC:  collea...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:collea...@mylocalhost.com>

Again, in this case, everyone receives their email as expected.

Scenario 3:
TO:  b...@microsoft.com<mailto:b...@microsoft.com>
BCC:  ad...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:ad...@mylocalhost.com>
BCC:  collea...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:collea...@mylocalhost.com>

In this case, neither
ad...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:ad...@mylocalhost.com> nor
collea...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:collea...@mylocalhost.com> receive
the email.

Scenario 4:
TO:  ad...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:ad...@mylocalhost.com>
BCC:  ad...@externalcompany.com<mailto:ad...@externalcompany.com>
BCC: collea...@externalcompany.com<mailto:collea...@externalcompany.com>

In this case, ad...@mylocalhost.com<mailto:ad...@mylocalhost.com>
doesn't receive the email but the external recipients do receive the
email!

It appears that as long as the recipients are either all in external
domains or all in the same local domain, it works Ok.  But when a BCC:
recipient is specified and the other recipients are split across
external and internal domains, the local recipients never get the mail
regardless of whether they were in the BCC: or TO: fields.

Has anyone seen this behavior?

Thanks,
Rich

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: server-user-unsubscr...@james.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: server-user-h...@james.apache.org

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: server-user-unsubscr...@james.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: server-user-h...@james.apache.org

Reply via email to