On Sun, Feb 24, 2008 at 2:00 PM, Upayavira <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Not to be picky, but I don't yet see much that counts as progress > towards graduation - not that that is a bad thing, at this point.
I'd have to disagree. > I see a _huge_ amount of traffic, clearly a lot of development work. But > that does not count on iota towards graduation, in itself. With my apache hat on, I disagree. It counts, but not in a big way. Running a productive project is important. > * Are folks collaborating according to the Apache way? >From what I can see, it looks pretty good so far. I spoke with all of the Google devs who are working on Shindig before it even entered the Incubator, and I'm reasonably sure that they get it and understand the importance of doing things the Apache way. > * Has the strong bias towards Google amongst committers been reduced? This is something that needs work. > * Has all IP been checked and cleared? > > * Has the project made a suitable incubator based release? (for IP > vetting purposes, not necessarily for public consumption) As far as I can tell, the IP has been completely vetted and contributed. > These are a few of the issues that occur to me immediately that would > help towards graduation, with the second likely being the most > significant, and hardest to resolve. It always is on projects that spring out of a single company :-) that said, if you have any specific concerns with examples, I think it would be useful to discuss them here. -Fitz
