Hi Shindig Dev,

I have a question regarding to Shindig Error coodes.

According to http://markmail.org/message/ahwnla6mnfkmswxr the Error code for
Limit Exceeded should be 409 as it can be used for both conflict and limit
exceeded. But In JsonRPC container js file it is 417 written for checking
the Limit exceeding error. In Restful container js file there is a place
holder for the same. In PHP Shindig its 509 for the same.

Accroding to opensocial-and-gadgets-spec discussion it should be 409. But by
the definition 509 it seems to be more correct. However, 509 is not an
official status code(see
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_HTTP_status_codes).
My question is what should be the correct code 509 or 409 or or
507(suggested in PHP comment) 417:P ? And shouldn't that code be
homegenously used across all the implementations?

any suggestions or comments ?

should I post this on opensocial-and-gadgets-spec list too as a proposal ?

Astha

Reply via email to