On 09/10/2010, at 2:15 AM, Stephen Kent wrote:
> 
>> > NEW:       When generating subject names, CAs SHOULD use a mechanism (such 
>> > as
>>>     those described [cert-profile]) to minimize the likelihood that
>>>     the subject name is a trademark, service mark, etc.
>> 
>> why not stick to has no meaning?  mentioning trade/service marks is an
>> unnecessary invitation to people we would rather not have to talk to
>> about this stuff.
> 
> Sean asked us to add the trademark text, because it is common in CPs. I agree 
> that it is inappropriate to impose a burden of this sort on the orgs that we 
> are asking to act as CAs here. Not mentioning this issue does not provide 
> "cover" for these orgs. Saying that a CA that employs the recommended name 
> gen technique, or an analogous mechanism, gets a pass, may provide cover, so 
> I think it is worthwhile.  But, if most WG members are more comfortable with 
> deleting this, let us know, and we'll remove it.
> 

I, for one, am more comfortable with deleting this.

thanks

  Geoff
_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to