I am speaking here as co-chair, but without a coordinated position with my co-chair, so take this as a personal position.

Part of doing the shepherding document writeup for a publication request is to attest that the shepherd has personally run idnits on the draft.

You may be surprised to learn that none of the drafts that were past wglc passed the idnits.

The routing ADs have indicated a distaste for drafts that do not pass idnits. There are various levels of idnit-ness. The strongest objection was to references that did not have the right name, making reviewing difficult. But the distaste applied to all.

For a document to be published, idnits will have to be addressed in some way at some point in the process. It is true that idnits does warn about things that are not fixable (version numbers in referenced drafts being a good example). But fixing easily fixable things saves time, messages, angst, keystrokes....

Document hygiene.  An idea whose time has come.

--Sandy
_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to