On Fri, Feb 18, 2011 at 9:54 AM, Sandra Murphy <[email protected]> wrote: > I am speaking here as co-chair, but without a coordinated position with my > co-chair, so take this as a personal position.
i agree with the below... > Part of doing the shepherding document writeup for a publication request is > to attest that the shepherd has personally run idnits on the draft. > > You may be surprised to learn that none of the drafts that were past wglc > passed the idnits. > > The routing ADs have indicated a distaste for drafts that do not pass > idnits. There are various levels of idnit-ness. The strongest objection > was to references that did not have the right name, making reviewing > difficult. But the distaste applied to all. > > For a document to be published, idnits will have to be addressed in some way > at some point in the process. It is true that idnits does warn about things > that are not fixable (version numbers in referenced drafts being a good > example). But fixing easily fixable things saves time, messages, angst, > keystrokes.... > > Document hygiene. An idea whose time has come. not JUST a good idea! :) thanks! -chris _______________________________________________ sidr mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr
