On May 31, 2011, at 10:23 AM, Randy Bush wrote: >> 1. Maybe add to section 5.9 "An Error Report PDU MUST NOT be sent for >> an Error Report PDU.". > > makes sense > >> To answer the initial request, it seems reasonable to specify "the >> length of the Arbitrary Text of Error Diagnostic Message MUST NOT be >> longer than 200 octets". That keeps the length of the entire PDU under >> the semi-magic 256 octets for the current version of the protocol > > in what way is 256 octets semi-magic?
C or assembly-based implementations will need to malloc (etc.) the buffer for the incoming message. Having that fit into 256 octets could easily have some value to some implementations. There is no security problem if the cache ignores such a MUST and makes the message longer because the length is given the PDU. (Having said that, I hope router implementers of this protocol are being robust in checking the lengths in this PDU; I can already see ways to craft malicious versions of this PDU that might trigger a buffer overflow...) One can say a lot in 200 octets, even of UTF8. --Paul Hoffman _______________________________________________ sidr mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr
