Steve,
It’s more explicit and better to understand.
But I suggest eliminating the expression concerning NIR that is “Case
1 also encompasses a larger case, e.g., when all of the ISPs with a country
require protection for an RIR action of this sort, coordinated at a national
level. We cannot assume that the country operates an NIR."
INR management in a country with NIR could be very complicated, with
different operation models. If necessay , a separate operation doc might be
presented, getting NIR stuff involved.
Di Ma
Internet Domain Name System Beijing Engineering Research Centre (ZDNS)
KNET Technologies
在 2014年3月4日，下午3:19，Stephen Kent <[email protected]> 写道：
> Randy,
>
> here is my suggestion for text that is not so folksy and is clearer (at least
> to me).
>
> Steve
>
> 4. Example Uses
>
> Case 1:
> ISP C find that its CA certificate has been be revoked (or modified to
> removed resources) by the RIR (or ISP) that issued it. ISP C believes that
> this revocation was either an error by RIR staff, or that the RIR has been
> compelled to revoke the certificate by a law enforcement agency in the
> jurisdiction where the RIR operates. ISP C would like other ISPs to be able
> to ignore the certificate revocation (or modification), at their discretion.
>
> Case 1 also encompasses a larger case, e.g., when all of the ISPs with a
> country require protection for an RIR action of this sort, coordinated at a
> national level. We cannot assume that the country operates an NIR.
>
> Case 2:
> ISP B makes use of private address space (RFC 1918) or makes use of address
> space allocated to some other party , but which is not announced globally).
> ISP B makes use of the RPKI internally, as well as for global routing. ISP B
> would like its use of private address space to work internally with routers
> that make use of RPKI data.
>
> Case 3:
> An organization, A, is authorized to control routing of traffic from a set of
> ISPs to the rest of the Internet. (For example, A may want traffic to
> selected addresses to be redirected to other addresses, or be dropped.)
> Because these ISPs want to use the RPKI, A needs a way to coordinate their
> use of the RPKI (in support of A’s traffic management goal).
> _______________________________________________
> sidr mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr
_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr
