Karen, I disagree with your position. Our draft does not explore adverse actions nor discuses transfers.
It is not the same topic. -Carlos On 11/6/15 5:53 AM, Karen Seo wrote: > Folks, > > I think the authors have brought up some pertinent issues which have > helped inspire other work which subsumes them. So I thank them but > agree that it seems appropriate to drop this draft since those issues > are now being covered in other documents and those documents have > additional detail. Randy's I-D discusses INR transfers. Steve's draft > on adverse action provides a detailed analysis of the "operational > fragility" of the RPKI in the face of attacks and errors. So, if the > adverse actions draft is adopted by the WG, we (the WG) could use the > requirements stemming from these two IDs as the basis for a solution(s) > document. Just personal preference, but I also find having one document > per topic/issue (at least when they're as complex as is the case with > the threat analysis) easier to follow and would also like to separate > defining of issues and their requirements from describing the solution. > > Respectfully, > Karen > > On 11/3/15 4:21 AM, Christopher Morrow wrote: >> During the meeting today (tues 11/3/2015) one of the authors of: >> draft-ietf-sidr-rpki-validation-reconsidered >> >> noted that after the last set of updates and over the history of the >> document (2+yrs) there's been no real support nor direction from the >> working-group. Additionally, all co-authors noted that the lack of >> support and direction meant that abandoning the draft seemed like the >> best current direction. >> >> The primary author: Geoff Huston ([email protected]) is willing to toss >> the XML over the fence to another author/editor if there is interest, >> or to let the draft expire/die if no one is willing to take up the >> pencil. >> >> Over the next three weeks let's discuss the direction/end-goal and >> determine if 'abandon' or 'new author' is the best course of action >> here. >> >> -chris >> sidr-co-chair >> >> _______________________________________________ >> sidr mailing list >> [email protected] >> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr > > _______________________________________________ > sidr mailing list > [email protected] > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr _______________________________________________ sidr mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr
