I don't comment on policy proposals as I believe that in my role as chair neutrality is very important.
I am going to comment on this matter as I believe that having all the policy in one document would make my task as chair more straightforward. I think this option of one document with separate chapters/sections is a good way to do this. On Tue, Feb 18, 2014 at 9:29 AM, Adam Gosling <[email protected]> wrote: > Hello Owen > > That makes me think of another option I haven’t listed. > > We could take the structure outlined in option 4 and put them all in one > document. That way we would have all the definitions, goals, and principles > information at the beginning of the document and then have three sections > IPv4, IPv6, and ASNs. > > One of the concerns with option 2 was the way Section 6 swaps back and > forth between the three resource types. > > So I present Option 5 structure below. It would achieve the goal of one > policy document with all its advantages, but keep the various resource > policy criteria quite distinct. > > > ------------------------------- > OPTION 5: One Policy Document > ------------------------------- > > Section 1: Policy Environment > ----------------------------- > 1.1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Distribution Hierarchy > 1.2. Definitions > All definitions > 1.3. Policy framework > Goals & Principles > 1.4. Resource License > Validity, renewal, recovery > 1.5. Resource Management > APNIC pool management > Historical resources > LIR responsibilities > 1.6. General requirements for requests > 1.7. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional transfers IPv4 & ASNs > Inter-RIR transfers IPv4 & ASNs > Historical resources > Mergers, acquisitions > 1.8. Experimental allocations > > > Section 2: IPv4 Policy > ---------------------- > 2.1. IPv4 Resource requests > Criteria for initial IPv4 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv4 delegations > 2.2. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional IPv4 transfers > Inter-RIR IPv4 transfers > Historical resources > Mergers, acquisitions > > > Section 3: IPv6 Policy > ---------------------- > 3.1. IPv6 Resource requests > Criteria for initial IPv6 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 allocations > Criteria for initial IPv6 assignments > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 assignments > 3.2. Resource Transfers > Mergers, acquisitions > 3.3. Appendix A : HD-Ratio > > > Section 4: ASN Policy > --------------------- > 4.1. ASN Resource requests > Criteria for ASN delegations > 4.2. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional ASN transfers > Inter-RIR ASN transfers > Mergers, acquisitions > > > > > > > -- > Adam Gosling > Senior Policy Specialist email: [email protected] > APNIC sip: [email protected] > http://www.apnic.net phone: +61 7 3858 3100 > ________________________________________________________________________ > * Sent by email to save paper. Print only if necessary. > > On 18/02/2014 12:26 am, "Owen DeLong" <[email protected]> wrote: > > I support option 2. > > It is hard enough trying to follow the regional policy differences as an > international network. > At least being able to find each regions policies in a single document > would be a monumental > improvement. > > Owen > > On Feb 16, 2014, at 21:33 , Adam Gosling <[email protected]> wrote: > > Dear Colleagues > > Many of you may recall that the APNIC Secretariat has been working > toward a restructure of the policy documents that govern the management > of resources in the region. > > Last March, I circulated a draft document that merged all seven policy > documents into one policy manual. The email containing the links to > those drafts is available here: > > > http://mailman.apnic.net/mailing-lists/sig-policy/archive/2013/03/msg00002.html > > Since then I have had some feedback that some may find a different > approach easier. Accordingly, I have identified below, a series of four > options. These range from no change - maintain the seven separate > documents, to keeping three or four documents. > > To give a sense of what this might look like, I've pasted a likely Table > of Contents for each policy according to the structure of each option. > > I can discuss this in more detail at APNIC 37, but the idea is to either > put all policies together in one policy manual, or to maintain separate > IPv4, IPv6, and AS number documents. > > I look forward to feedback and opinions from community members, either > on this list, or at the meeting. > > Kind Regards, > > Adam > > > -- > Adam Gosling > Senior Policy Specialist email: [email protected] > APNIC sip: [email protected] > http://www.apnic.net phone: +61 7 3858 3100 > ________________________________________________________________________ > * Sent by email to save paper. Print only if necessary. > > > > ------------------- > OPTION 1: No Change > ------------------- > > Policy Environment > IPv4 Policy > IPv6 Policy > Experimental Policy > ASN Policy > Transfers Policy > Historical Resource Policy > > > -------------------- > OPTION 2: One Policy > -------------------- > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Distribution Hierarchy > 2. Definitions > All definitions > 3. Policy framework > Goals & Principles > 4. Resource License > Validity, renewal, recovery > 5. Resource Management > APNIC pool management > Historical resources > LIR responsibilities > 6. Resource requests > General requirements for requests > Criteria for initial IPv4 delegations > Criteria for initial IPv6 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv4 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 allocations > Criteria for initial IPv6 assignments > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 assignments > Criteria for ASN delegations > Experimental allocations > 7. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional transfers IPv4 & ASNs > Inter-RIR transfers IPv4 & ASNs > Historical resources > Mergers, acquisitions > 8. Appendix A : HD-Ratio > > > -------------------------------- > OPTION 3: Three Policy Documents > -------------------------------- > > IPv4 Policy > ----------- > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Distribution Hierarchy > 2. Definitions > Relevant definitions only > 3. Policy framework > Goals & Principles > 4. Resource License > Validity, renewal, recovery > 5. Resource Management > APNIC pool management > Historical resources > LIR responsibilities > 6. Resource requests > General requirements for requests > Criteria for initial IPv4 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv4 delegations > Experimental allocations > 7. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional IPv4 transfers > Inter-RIR IPv4 transfers > Historical resources > Mergers, acquisitions > > > IPv6 Policy > ----------- > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Distribution Hierarchy > 2. Definitions > Relevant definitions only > 3. Policy framework > Goals & Principles > 4. Resource License > Validity, renewal, recovery > 5. Resource Management > APNIC pool management > LIR responsibilities > 6. Resource requests > General requirements for requests > Criteria for initial IPv6 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 allocations > Criteria for initial IPv6 assignments > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 assignments > Experimental allocations > 7. Resource Transfers > Mergers, acquisitions > 8. Appendix A : HD-Ratio > > > ASN Policy > ---------- > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy & Distribution Hierarchy > 2. Definitions > Relevant definitions only > 3. Policy framework > Goals & Principles > 4. Resource License > Validity, renewal, recovery > 5. Resource Management > APNIC pool management > Historical resources > LIR responsibilities > 6. Resource requests > General requirements for requests > Criteria for ASN delegations > Experimental allocations > 7. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional ASN transfers > Inter-RIR ASN transfers > Mergers, acquisitions > > > ------------------------------- > OPTION 4: Four Policy Documents > ------------------------------- > > Policy Environment > ------------------ > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Distribution Hierarchy > 2. Definitions > All definitions > 3. Policy framework > Goals & Principles > 4. Resource License > Validity, renewal, recovery > 5. Resource Management > APNIC pool management > Historical resources > LIR responsibilities > 6. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional transfers IPv4 & ASNs > Inter-RIR transfers IPv4 & ASNs > Historical resources > Mergers, acquisitions > 7. Experimental allocations > 8. Appendix A : HD-Ratio > > > IPv4 Policy > ----------- > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Subject to Policy Environment > 2. Resource requests > General requirements for requests > Criteria for initial IPv4 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv4 delegations > 7. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional IPv4 transfers > Inter-RIR IPv4 transfers > Historical resources > Mergers, acquisitions > > > IPv6 Policy > ----------- > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Subject to Policy Environment > 2. Resource requests > General requirements for requests > Criteria for initial IPv6 delegations > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 allocations > Criteria for initial IPv6 assignments > Criteria for subsequent IPv6 assignments > 7. Resource Transfers > Mergers, acquisitions > 8. Appendix A : HD-Ratio > > > ASN Policy > ---------- > 1. Introduction > Scope of Policy > Subject to Policy Environment > 2. Resource requests > General requirements for requests > Criteria for ASN delegations > 7. Resource Transfers > Intra-Regional ASN transfers > Inter-RIR ASN transfers > Mergers, acquisitions > > > * sig-policy: APNIC SIG on resource management policy > * > _______________________________________________ > sig-policy mailing list > [email protected] > http://mailman.apnic.net/mailman/listinfo/sig-policy > > > > * sig-policy: APNIC SIG on resource management policy > * > _______________________________________________ > sig-policy mailing list > [email protected] > http://mailman.apnic.net/mailman/listinfo/sig-policy > >
* sig-policy: APNIC SIG on resource management policy * _______________________________________________ sig-policy mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.apnic.net/mailman/listinfo/sig-policy
