This is a good article.  It touches on real pain points that brought the
industry to passkeys. If someone like Troy Hunt  - a guy who has found fame
and fortune dealing with insecure passwords  (and mentioned in the article)
- got phished, what chance do normies in our lives have?

Passkeys are designed to address many known password pain points including
making it *much *harder for developers to screw things up (*one* of the
reasons password managers failed to capture the market). It is impossible
to fix passwords; passkeys are the future. Let's dig deeper into some good
points the article makes about the current flaws of passkeys.

*> “It may get to a point where we’re all using passkeys and we don’t even
know we’re using passkeys,” Lorrie Cranor, a computer-science professor at
Carnegie Mellon University who researches privacy and cybersecurity, told
me. “I just say ‘Log in’ and I smile at it, and it gets my passkey, and I’m
logged in.”*

*> But that future isn’t here yet,*

The internet is vast. "That future" is here today for a large and growing
chunk of users. Meta recently announced
<https://blog.whatsapp.com/one-billion-people-are-now-protected-with-passkeys-on-whatsapp-plus-more-account-security-features>
that 1 billion WhatsApp users have passkeys. Google announced in *2024 *that
over 400 million accounts use passkeys (You can assume it has grown a lot
in the 2 years hence). Prof Lorrie Cranor says it is possible many people
don't even know they are using passkeys; this is true. Equally, qualitative
surveys show users feel passkeys are simpler and more secure than
passwords. Amazon, Ebay, Microsoft, Paypal, TikTok and other large
companies show similarly impressive qualitative and quant results.

But of course, this doesn't mean the other problems can be dismissed. The
internet is diverse and we need everyone to become comfortable with this
new way of doing things.

*> Part of the problem is that virtually no one seems to know what they
are. “The fact that even I have trouble explaining them should be a clue,”
Cranor said.*

We actually hear this constantly, but *only* from users at the upper end of
the tech savviness spectrum.  Others tend to worry about things like, "*So
I don't have to remember another password?!"* or "*Does Google get my face?*"",
basically what it means for them and what it lets them do etc. BTW, my mini
survey got only 2 responses - too few to make any grand connections; I have
included the responses verbatim in the postscript.

In my opinion this leaves us in a weird state: on the one hand it does not
matter because normal people are happily using passkeys already and the
numbers support this. On the other hand, the unhappiness of some tech-savvy
people creates confusion at best and needless FUD at worst. Tech-savvy
people act as mini-influencers within their social groups. So this
marketing problem is very real, unsolved, and has our attention.

*> *To further complicate matters, *passkeys generally aren’t yet replacing
passwords altogether, even on sites that use them*

This has been the case so far. The general idea has been to give users
plenty of time to get used to a new technology. However this is already
starting to change, with some services already supporting the creation of
new accounts without a password at all. You can expect more "passwordless"
accounts in the next couple of years.

*>  Because many passkeys live on your device, one that works on your phone
might not work on your laptop*

This is not correct. You can use a passkey on your phone to login to that
account on your laptop. For e.g. If you created a passkey on your iPhone
for your Amazon account, you can try to sign in with a passkey on your
parent's Windows laptop and select the option to use another device, you
can then scan a QR code with your phone and be signed in. This is not as
convenient as using a passkey on the laptop itself, so Amazon might prompt
you to create another passkey for that device.

*> one that works on your personal laptop might not work on your office
device.*

If we're talking about a personal *phone* then this would work exactly like
the previous case, but because "scan a QR code using a laptop camera" is
not practical this is not a supported flow.

*> It’s a lot, Dave Lewis, 1Password’s global-security adviser,
acknowledged to me in an email.*

I think this is a fair comment in some ways. And the article has not even
touched on the hairier aspects. In the defense of passkeys, the thing that
tech-savvy people tend to overlook is that overall experience is actually
simple for common scenarios "most people" encounter (such as a single
ecosystem or multi-device users with at least one phone), but the system is
also flexible enough to handle power-user scenarios, all while balancing
many complex ecosystem considerations that moves an entire industry
forward. Consequently, things become more challenging as the scenario
becomes more complex.

We have a long road ahead, but the wind is very much at our back!

-Karra

P.S.

*Survey Response 1:*

1. A password is my personal combination to open my locker - nobody else
has it. Ideally it would die when I die (virtually and or really).

2. My mom's concept: keys to the house. Others may also have the same key.

*Survey Response 2:*

I think a password uses something only you would know as proof  that you
are who you say you are (with your ID/email of whatever your claim is).
Secret questions/answers make this very literal.

And I think the least savvy person might think it’s a jumble of letters
that no one else can guess. Something that gets you access to a restricted
area.

On Wed, Aug 26, 2026 at 11:00 PM Sriram Karra <[email protected]> wrote:

> This is a topic close to my heart of course. Before I share more thoughts,
> I have a favor to ask:
>
> Part 1: Can folks reading this send me a note *off-list, *answering this
> question: "What is a password?" - the answer must make sense to someone who
> has never used a password on a website before. You can assume this
> hypothetical person has been using some other "unknown" technique to log in
> to their favourite websites before this newfangled technology called a
> password was introduced.
>
> Part 2: Now, also take a shot at what you think the "least tech savvy"
> person in your life would say to that question.
>
> -Karra
>
> On Mon, Aug 24, 2026 at 8:26 PM Udhay Shankar N via Silklist <
> [email protected]> wrote:
>
>> At least one member <https://www.linkedin.com/in/sriramkarra/> of this
>> list has a day job that is designed to specifically address this problem,
>> at a scale that is probably unmatched anywhere else. (I have no qualms
>> about outing him here because he has posted about this very issue on this
>> very list). I'd be interested in his comments, and the rest of the list as
>> well.
>>
>> Udhay
>>
>>
>> https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/08/password-manager-login-difficulty/688396
>>
>> Logging in Was Never Supposed to Be This Complicated
>> Please not another two-factor authentication code.
>>
>> By Will Oremus
>> August 24, 2026, 5:06 PM ET
>>
>> One afternoon earlier this month, I pulled up to the rec center and
>> realized that I had a problem. It was not the three boisterous tweens in
>> the back seat who were clamoring to be set loose in the basketball gym. It
>> was my parking app. I had somehow gotten logged out of Passport Parking,
>> which has become the only way to pay for a spot in much of my town, and it
>> was demanding a four-digit PIN to let me back in. My first guess drew a
>> warning message in red letters: “Invalid PIN. PIN cannot contain 4
>> sequential numbers, 2 repeated digits, or the last 4 digits of your phone
>> number.” I searched my trusty password manager, which was supposed to spare
>> me these predicaments, but it came up empty. By that point, the kids had
>> run ahead and piled themselves against the gym door, waiting for me to let
>> them in.
>>
>> Lately, the process of accessing apps and websites has grown dizzying.
>> “I’m in password hell,” a colleague confided to me recently. “Every login
>> attempt is playing the lottery.” The problem is not just the sheer number
>> of digital accounts, all of which require their own password, ideally
>> unique and unguessable (which usually also means un-memorizable). It’s the
>> pileup of solutions to that problem: all of the different layers of
>> software offering to remember your passwords, the six-digit codes sent to
>> your phone, the authenticator apps, the passkeys.
>>
>> Browsers and operating systems compete with third-party password managers
>> to generate, store, and autofill your credentials. Most of my logins live
>> in 1Password, but others are stored in Apple’s Passwords app (usually by
>> accident), and still others were created via “single sign-on” features such
>> as those offered by Google and Facebook. I vaguely recall certain
>> apps—Facebook is one—prompting me many years ago to copy down a set of
>> “login recovery codes” that would become extremely important should I ever
>> get locked out of my account. Whatever device I stored them on was probably
>> wiped and sold long ago.
>>
>> Logins have always been a hassle. In the 1990s, forgetting your password
>> sometimes meant mailing a postcard to your service provider and waiting a
>> week or two for it to mail you a new password. In the early 2010s, hackers
>> learned to steal massive troves of logins and then reuse them on other
>> services to steal people’s identities. Things spiraled from there; services
>> started requiring unique, complex passwords with arbitrary requirements.
>> These days, the user experience of logging in is “probably worse than
>> ever,” Troy Hunt, a cybersecurity expert who runs the website Have I Been
>> Pwned, told me. “There’s just no consistency.”
>>
>> Password managers promised a way out, but they often don’t work as
>> seamlessly as you might hope. I click to autofill my password somewhere,
>> and a 1Password authorization appears, only for an iCloud Keychain
>> authorization to pop up directly over it, preventing me from clicking on
>> the 1Password one. When I manually enter a login I thought I remembered, my
>> browser prompts me to remember it; only after I hit “Save” (pro tip: Do not
>> do this) does the website inform me that the password was not recognized.
>> Even when you log in successfully, there’s the tedious dance of waiting for
>> a six-digit authorization code to appear on your phone or in your email,
>> which defeats the concept of a single password for everything. And if
>> you’re somewhere without cell service or you’re sharing a login with
>> someone who isn’t around, you might just be out of luck.
>>
>> All of these steps serve a purpose. At least in theory, each added layer
>> helps prevent hacks and breaches. Erring on the side of safety is worth an
>> amount of inconvenience. At the same time, extra steps can introduce
>> security problems of their own. Last year, Hunt fell for a clever phishing
>> scheme when he clicked a link to log in to his newsletter service. His
>> password manager failed to autofill his information, which should have
>> alerted him that something was wrong, he said. But like the rest of us, he
>> was so used to things not working that he went ahead and manually entered
>> his credentials on a site that turned out to be an impostor, designed to
>> steal and exploit them.
>>
>> None of these obstacles is insurmountable on its own. My problem with
>> Apple’s native password manager fighting with 1Password, for instance, was
>> eventually solved with a 10-minute foray into the bowels of my device
>> settings. But together, they amount to a near-daily irritant. For the less
>> tech-savvy, the situation can be overwhelming. My recent attempts to help
>> my mother fix her password-storage system—which involved loose-leaf notepad
>> sheets full of hand-scrawled credentials scattered around her house like
>> Easter eggs—consumed the better part of a day. By the end, she had all of
>> her credentials updated, validated, and stored in a password manager, just
>> as the experts have been advising for years. But even then, her preferred
>> browser, Google Chrome, showed no interest in surfacing the credentials we
>> had stashed in Apple’s Keychain. And some websites short-circuited her
>> attempts to log in by prompting her to set up a “passkey,” which she
>> interpreted as meaning that her password had failed and she needed to scrap
>> it and set up a new one.
>>
>> Cybersecurity experts will tell you that passkeys—which typically entail
>> logging in to apps or websites with a face or fingerprint scan instead of a
>> password—are the future. When they work properly, they’re both painless and
>> secure. “It may get to a point where we’re all using passkeys and we don’t
>> even know we’re using passkeys,” Lorrie Cranor, a computer-science
>> professor at Carnegie Mellon University who researches privacy and
>> cybersecurity, told me. “I just say ‘Log in’ and I smile at it, and it gets
>> my passkey, and I’m logged in.”
>>
>> But that future isn’t here yet, and in the present, passkeys have added a
>> new layer of frustration. Part of the problem is that virtually no one
>> seems to know what they are. “The fact that even I have trouble explaining
>> them should be a clue,” Cranor said. Her past research on the rollout of
>> two-factor authentication suggests that most people tend to resist new
>> security features for as long as they can. Companies can nudge them, but
>> for websites and apps trying to attract and retain users, pushing people to
>> adopt an unfamiliar authentication technology risks scaring them away.
>>
>> To further complicate matters, passkeys generally aren’t yet replacing
>> passwords altogether, even on sites that use them. Because many passkeys
>> live on your device, one that works on your phone might not work on your
>> laptop, and one that works on your personal laptop might not work on your
>> office device. So you still need a password that works across devices as a
>> backup. It’s a lot, Dave Lewis, 1Password’s global-security adviser,
>> acknowledged to me in an email. “The problem is cognitive overload,” he
>> said. “All these tools are trying to help, but they don’t always work
>> together intuitively.” Still, he disagreed that the situation has never
>> been worse: “When the alternative was using the same password across dozens
>> of accounts or putting it on a sticky note, the fact that people now have
>> password managers, passkeys, biometrics, and multifactor authentication is
>> a good thing.”
>>
>> The mess might compound before it improves. Hacking attempts have been
>> multiplying as crooks harness AI tools. Companies are adding even more
>> security layers that make logging in harder, and they are pleading for
>> people to make the switch to passkeys. On the bright side, maybe the
>> seamless biometric future is actually within sight, and all of our login
>> woes will soon be over. Then again, that’s what we were promised with
>> password managers too.
>>
>> About the Author
>>
>> Will Oremus
>> Will Oremus is a staff writer at The Atlantic.
>>
>>
>> --
>>
>> ((Udhay Shankar N)) ((udhay @ pobox.com)) ((www.digeratus.com))
>>
>> --
>> Silklist mailing list
>> [email protected]
>> https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist
>>
>
-- 
Silklist mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist

Reply via email to