A friend recently passed away. A few of us are helping his widow navigate the tangle of home IT and financial "systems" that he had.
I shudder to think what it would be like if he had used a passkey to log in; it's already difficult enough. On August 28, 2026 7:04:49 PM PDT, Sriram Karra via Silklist <[email protected]> wrote: >This is a good article. It touches on real pain points that brought the >industry to passkeys. If someone like Troy Hunt - a guy who has found fame >and fortune dealing with insecure passwords (and mentioned in the article) >- got phished, what chance do normies in our lives have? > >Passkeys are designed to address many known password pain points including >making it *much *harder for developers to screw things up (*one* of the >reasons password managers failed to capture the market). It is impossible >to fix passwords; passkeys are the future. Let's dig deeper into some good >points the article makes about the current flaws of passkeys. > >*> “It may get to a point where we’re all using passkeys and we don’t even >know we’re using passkeys,” Lorrie Cranor, a computer-science professor at >Carnegie Mellon University who researches privacy and cybersecurity, told >me. “I just say ‘Log in’ and I smile at it, and it gets my passkey, and I’m >logged in.”* > >*> But that future isn’t here yet,* > >The internet is vast. "That future" is here today for a large and growing >chunk of users. Meta recently announced ><https://blog.whatsapp.com/one-billion-people-are-now-protected-with-passkeys-on-whatsapp-plus-more-account-security-features> >that 1 billion WhatsApp users have passkeys. Google announced in *2024 *that >over 400 million accounts use passkeys (You can assume it has grown a lot >in the 2 years hence). Prof Lorrie Cranor says it is possible many people >don't even know they are using passkeys; this is true. Equally, qualitative >surveys show users feel passkeys are simpler and more secure than >passwords. Amazon, Ebay, Microsoft, Paypal, TikTok and other large >companies show similarly impressive qualitative and quant results. > >But of course, this doesn't mean the other problems can be dismissed. The >internet is diverse and we need everyone to become comfortable with this >new way of doing things. > >*> Part of the problem is that virtually no one seems to know what they >are. “The fact that even I have trouble explaining them should be a clue,” >Cranor said.* > >We actually hear this constantly, but *only* from users at the upper end of >the tech savviness spectrum. Others tend to worry about things like, "*So >I don't have to remember another password?!"* or "*Does Google get my face?*"", >basically what it means for them and what it lets them do etc. BTW, my mini >survey got only 2 responses - too few to make any grand connections; I have >included the responses verbatim in the postscript. > >In my opinion this leaves us in a weird state: on the one hand it does not >matter because normal people are happily using passkeys already and the >numbers support this. On the other hand, the unhappiness of some tech-savvy >people creates confusion at best and needless FUD at worst. Tech-savvy >people act as mini-influencers within their social groups. So this >marketing problem is very real, unsolved, and has our attention. > >*> *To further complicate matters, *passkeys generally aren’t yet replacing >passwords altogether, even on sites that use them* > >This has been the case so far. The general idea has been to give users >plenty of time to get used to a new technology. However this is already >starting to change, with some services already supporting the creation of >new accounts without a password at all. You can expect more "passwordless" >accounts in the next couple of years. > >*> Because many passkeys live on your device, one that works on your phone >might not work on your laptop* > >This is not correct. You can use a passkey on your phone to login to that >account on your laptop. For e.g. If you created a passkey on your iPhone >for your Amazon account, you can try to sign in with a passkey on your >parent's Windows laptop and select the option to use another device, you >can then scan a QR code with your phone and be signed in. This is not as >convenient as using a passkey on the laptop itself, so Amazon might prompt >you to create another passkey for that device. > >*> one that works on your personal laptop might not work on your office >device.* > >If we're talking about a personal *phone* then this would work exactly like >the previous case, but because "scan a QR code using a laptop camera" is >not practical this is not a supported flow. > >*> It’s a lot, Dave Lewis, 1Password’s global-security adviser, >acknowledged to me in an email.* > >I think this is a fair comment in some ways. And the article has not even >touched on the hairier aspects. In the defense of passkeys, the thing that >tech-savvy people tend to overlook is that overall experience is actually >simple for common scenarios "most people" encounter (such as a single >ecosystem or multi-device users with at least one phone), but the system is >also flexible enough to handle power-user scenarios, all while balancing >many complex ecosystem considerations that moves an entire industry >forward. Consequently, things become more challenging as the scenario >becomes more complex. > >We have a long road ahead, but the wind is very much at our back! > >-Karra > >P.S. > >*Survey Response 1:* > >1. A password is my personal combination to open my locker - nobody else >has it. Ideally it would die when I die (virtually and or really). > >2. My mom's concept: keys to the house. Others may also have the same key. > >*Survey Response 2:* > >I think a password uses something only you would know as proof that you >are who you say you are (with your ID/email of whatever your claim is). >Secret questions/answers make this very literal. > >And I think the least savvy person might think it’s a jumble of letters >that no one else can guess. Something that gets you access to a restricted >area. > >On Wed, Aug 26, 2026 at 11:00 PM Sriram Karra <[email protected]> wrote: > >> This is a topic close to my heart of course. Before I share more thoughts, >> I have a favor to ask: >> >> Part 1: Can folks reading this send me a note *off-list, *answering this >> question: "What is a password?" - the answer must make sense to someone who >> has never used a password on a website before. You can assume this >> hypothetical person has been using some other "unknown" technique to log in >> to their favourite websites before this newfangled technology called a >> password was introduced. >> >> Part 2: Now, also take a shot at what you think the "least tech savvy" >> person in your life would say to that question. >> >> -Karra >> >> On Mon, Aug 24, 2026 at 8:26 PM Udhay Shankar N via Silklist < >> [email protected]> wrote: >> >>> At least one member <https://www.linkedin.com/in/sriramkarra/> of this >>> list has a day job that is designed to specifically address this problem, >>> at a scale that is probably unmatched anywhere else. (I have no qualms >>> about outing him here because he has posted about this very issue on this >>> very list). I'd be interested in his comments, and the rest of the list as >>> well. >>> >>> Udhay >>> >>> >>> https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/08/password-manager-login-difficulty/688396 >>> >>> Logging in Was Never Supposed to Be This Complicated >>> Please not another two-factor authentication code. >>> >>> By Will Oremus >>> August 24, 2026, 5:06 PM ET >>> >>> One afternoon earlier this month, I pulled up to the rec center and >>> realized that I had a problem. It was not the three boisterous tweens in >>> the back seat who were clamoring to be set loose in the basketball gym. It >>> was my parking app. I had somehow gotten logged out of Passport Parking, >>> which has become the only way to pay for a spot in much of my town, and it >>> was demanding a four-digit PIN to let me back in. My first guess drew a >>> warning message in red letters: “Invalid PIN. PIN cannot contain 4 >>> sequential numbers, 2 repeated digits, or the last 4 digits of your phone >>> number.” I searched my trusty password manager, which was supposed to spare >>> me these predicaments, but it came up empty. By that point, the kids had >>> run ahead and piled themselves against the gym door, waiting for me to let >>> them in. >>> >>> Lately, the process of accessing apps and websites has grown dizzying. >>> “I’m in password hell,” a colleague confided to me recently. “Every login >>> attempt is playing the lottery.” The problem is not just the sheer number >>> of digital accounts, all of which require their own password, ideally >>> unique and unguessable (which usually also means un-memorizable). It’s the >>> pileup of solutions to that problem: all of the different layers of >>> software offering to remember your passwords, the six-digit codes sent to >>> your phone, the authenticator apps, the passkeys. >>> >>> Browsers and operating systems compete with third-party password managers >>> to generate, store, and autofill your credentials. Most of my logins live >>> in 1Password, but others are stored in Apple’s Passwords app (usually by >>> accident), and still others were created via “single sign-on” features such >>> as those offered by Google and Facebook. I vaguely recall certain >>> apps—Facebook is one—prompting me many years ago to copy down a set of >>> “login recovery codes” that would become extremely important should I ever >>> get locked out of my account. Whatever device I stored them on was probably >>> wiped and sold long ago. >>> >>> Logins have always been a hassle. In the 1990s, forgetting your password >>> sometimes meant mailing a postcard to your service provider and waiting a >>> week or two for it to mail you a new password. In the early 2010s, hackers >>> learned to steal massive troves of logins and then reuse them on other >>> services to steal people’s identities. Things spiraled from there; services >>> started requiring unique, complex passwords with arbitrary requirements. >>> These days, the user experience of logging in is “probably worse than >>> ever,” Troy Hunt, a cybersecurity expert who runs the website Have I Been >>> Pwned, told me. “There’s just no consistency.” >>> >>> Password managers promised a way out, but they often don’t work as >>> seamlessly as you might hope. I click to autofill my password somewhere, >>> and a 1Password authorization appears, only for an iCloud Keychain >>> authorization to pop up directly over it, preventing me from clicking on >>> the 1Password one. When I manually enter a login I thought I remembered, my >>> browser prompts me to remember it; only after I hit “Save” (pro tip: Do not >>> do this) does the website inform me that the password was not recognized. >>> Even when you log in successfully, there’s the tedious dance of waiting for >>> a six-digit authorization code to appear on your phone or in your email, >>> which defeats the concept of a single password for everything. And if >>> you’re somewhere without cell service or you’re sharing a login with >>> someone who isn’t around, you might just be out of luck. >>> >>> All of these steps serve a purpose. At least in theory, each added layer >>> helps prevent hacks and breaches. Erring on the side of safety is worth an >>> amount of inconvenience. At the same time, extra steps can introduce >>> security problems of their own. Last year, Hunt fell for a clever phishing >>> scheme when he clicked a link to log in to his newsletter service. His >>> password manager failed to autofill his information, which should have >>> alerted him that something was wrong, he said. But like the rest of us, he >>> was so used to things not working that he went ahead and manually entered >>> his credentials on a site that turned out to be an impostor, designed to >>> steal and exploit them. >>> >>> None of these obstacles is insurmountable on its own. My problem with >>> Apple’s native password manager fighting with 1Password, for instance, was >>> eventually solved with a 10-minute foray into the bowels of my device >>> settings. But together, they amount to a near-daily irritant. For the less >>> tech-savvy, the situation can be overwhelming. My recent attempts to help >>> my mother fix her password-storage system—which involved loose-leaf notepad >>> sheets full of hand-scrawled credentials scattered around her house like >>> Easter eggs—consumed the better part of a day. By the end, she had all of >>> her credentials updated, validated, and stored in a password manager, just >>> as the experts have been advising for years. But even then, her preferred >>> browser, Google Chrome, showed no interest in surfacing the credentials we >>> had stashed in Apple’s Keychain. And some websites short-circuited her >>> attempts to log in by prompting her to set up a “passkey,” which she >>> interpreted as meaning that her password had failed and she needed to scrap >>> it and set up a new one. >>> >>> Cybersecurity experts will tell you that passkeys—which typically entail >>> logging in to apps or websites with a face or fingerprint scan instead of a >>> password—are the future. When they work properly, they’re both painless and >>> secure. “It may get to a point where we’re all using passkeys and we don’t >>> even know we’re using passkeys,” Lorrie Cranor, a computer-science >>> professor at Carnegie Mellon University who researches privacy and >>> cybersecurity, told me. “I just say ‘Log in’ and I smile at it, and it gets >>> my passkey, and I’m logged in.” >>> >>> But that future isn’t here yet, and in the present, passkeys have added a >>> new layer of frustration. Part of the problem is that virtually no one >>> seems to know what they are. “The fact that even I have trouble explaining >>> them should be a clue,” Cranor said. Her past research on the rollout of >>> two-factor authentication suggests that most people tend to resist new >>> security features for as long as they can. Companies can nudge them, but >>> for websites and apps trying to attract and retain users, pushing people to >>> adopt an unfamiliar authentication technology risks scaring them away. >>> >>> To further complicate matters, passkeys generally aren’t yet replacing >>> passwords altogether, even on sites that use them. Because many passkeys >>> live on your device, one that works on your phone might not work on your >>> laptop, and one that works on your personal laptop might not work on your >>> office device. So you still need a password that works across devices as a >>> backup. It’s a lot, Dave Lewis, 1Password’s global-security adviser, >>> acknowledged to me in an email. “The problem is cognitive overload,” he >>> said. “All these tools are trying to help, but they don’t always work >>> together intuitively.” Still, he disagreed that the situation has never >>> been worse: “When the alternative was using the same password across dozens >>> of accounts or putting it on a sticky note, the fact that people now have >>> password managers, passkeys, biometrics, and multifactor authentication is >>> a good thing.” >>> >>> The mess might compound before it improves. Hacking attempts have been >>> multiplying as crooks harness AI tools. Companies are adding even more >>> security layers that make logging in harder, and they are pleading for >>> people to make the switch to passkeys. On the bright side, maybe the >>> seamless biometric future is actually within sight, and all of our login >>> woes will soon be over. Then again, that’s what we were promised with >>> password managers too. >>> >>> About the Author >>> >>> Will Oremus >>> Will Oremus is a staff writer at The Atlantic. >>> >>> >>> -- >>> >>> ((Udhay Shankar N)) ((udhay @ pobox.com)) ((www.digeratus.com)) >>> >>> -- >>> Silklist mailing list >>> [email protected] >>> https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist >>> >>
-- Silklist mailing list [email protected] https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist
