In the aughts as "social media" was emerging I was giving various talks on the future of the Internet and/or the history of the Internet. I included a slide that showed the Internet stack overlaid by Facebook, expressing concern that Facebook (and similar services) would be how many people experienced the Internet in the future. I was saying that much of the promise of the Internet for community and diverse content could be smothered by systems that manipulated users, selling eyeballs to advertisers. Unfortunately I wasn't wrong. But this mainstreaming of enshittification hasn't completely destroyed the Internet. Communities still emerge, platforms that are not profit-driven still appear and succeed (e.g. Mastodon). I still long onto the WELL every day, as I've done for most of 36 years.
I do like that Campaign Asia Pacific piece. On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 9:20 AM Charles Haynes via Silklist < [email protected]> wrote: > Wait, so this article is about the poor advertisers getting enshittified? > > I could tell war stories about the early days of ads at Google and how > Larry had this vision of relevant ads adding value to the user experience. > My arguments with the ads folks about how brand ads were evil and buying > DoubleClick was the beginning of the end, but no. > > Let's just say I'm not shedding any tears about how hard online > advertisers have it. > > — Charles > > On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 at 22:09, Cindy Gallop <[email protected]> > wrote: > >> Apologies - article cut and pasted below for those interested: >> >> *Published in Campaign Asia Pacific Jan 20, 2025:* >> >> In the past couple of weeks, Mark Zuckerberg has shown us exactly who he >> is. >> >> Meta has axed fact-checking and content moderation, with, in its internal >> guidelines, some truly horrific statements of exactly what kind of hate >> speech is now considered acceptable—in line with right-wing Silicon Valley >> billionaires’ belief in ‘free speech for me but not for thee’. It’s >> abandoning all pretence at DEI in its hiring and retention policies. >> Zuckerberg has said that he feels Meta needs more "masculine energy", >> because it’s good if a culture "celebrates aggression a bit more". Like his >> fellow tech titans Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos, he’s kneeling at Trump’s feet, >> kissing the ring, and obeying in advance. >> >> There’s never been a better time for the advertising industry to show >> exactly who we are. But this isn’t an appeal for our industry to ‘do the >> right thing’. Yes, we should, but I’m under no illusion that such an appeal >> would actually work. Instead, this is an appeal for our industry to do four >> things that will make agencies, holding companies and our clients a lot >> more money. >> >> Do I have your attention now? >> >> *1. Flex our financial muscle* >> >> We’ve colluded in our own devaluation for decades—never more than with >> the Silicon Valley giants. People value you at the value you are seen to >> put on yourself, and we have not understood and projected the extraordinary >> value that we have. We are the business model for the internet. We are the >> reason Meta makes the billions it does. We are the reason for Mark >> Zuckerberg’s net worth, and why he wields the power he does. He would not >> be where he is today without advertising. >> >> But we gave that power away. For years, we’ve been pathetically grateful >> that these platforms have allowed us to advertise on them, rather than >> realising we’re in a position to call the shots. So—time to bring some >> ‘masculine energy’ and some ‘aggression’ to the table, to do the deals we >> want on our terms. Because without us, Meta and every other giant tech >> platform that relies on advertising is screwed. >> >> *2. Be creative about what WE want * >> >> Instead of automatically going, “We have to be on——why not start from >> the other end? We pride ourselves on extremely ingenious strategy and >> highly creative execution. Use that ingenuity and creativity to decide what >> the optimum brand experience/use of technology/campaign would be for our >> clients, demand that, and set our own terms and conditions. We’re entirely >> capable as an industry of developing far more creatively compelling ad >> products and approaches than the ones we’re being forcefed. >> >> *3. Protect our consumers * >> >> In a January 14 article by Katie Notopoulos for Business Insider titled, >> ‘Mark Zuckerberg says he wants more ‘masculine energy’ at Meta. So why >> don’t more men use Facebook?’, she writes, “I do worry that people have >> forgotten something that seems clear to me: Facebook is powered by feminine >> energy.” >> >> Research shows that women are more active on Facebook and Instagram than >> men. Meta is what it is today because of its female users. And women, let >> us not forget, are our target for all advertising—as the primary purchasers >> and influencers of purchases of everything. >> >> Content moderation keeps girls and women safe. Remove it, and sexism, >> misogyny and rape culture run rampant unchecked. >> >> We make more money when we protect our consumers, stand up for them, and >> demand better user experiences for them that keep them safe, happy, and >> more receptive to the messages we and our clients want to send them, and >> the brands and products we and our clients want them to buy. >> >> *4. Fund the female lens on advertising and tech * >> >> Six years ago, I spoke at Social Media Week New York, where I told the >> audience that existing social media platforms, no matter how gigantic, >> could be disrupted and toppled by the female/Black/of >> colour/LGBTQ/disabled/’other’ founders who build the safe social platforms >> of the future. That opportunity is even greater now, as the recent success >> of BlueSky demonstrates. >> >> For years I’ve exhorted the women of the ad industry to build adtech >> ventures—because adtech is as male-dominated as advertising and tech. We >> are constantly targeted and sold to through the male lens—when we know how >> to sell to ourselves. >> >> This isn’t just something I advocate for—I’m doing this myself because I >> see the huge opportunity. I shared my idea for HereForTheAds in my Cannes >> Lions keynote last year on ‘How To Change Advertising For the Better, >> Fast’—it’s adtech designed to sell by making people love ads. Shocker, >> right? >> >> Now is the time for our industry to invest in a different future for >> advertising—because we have not even begun to see how much safer, better, >> happier, more effective, and more lucrative that future could be when it’s >> powered by feminine energy, designed and built through the female lens at >> scale. >> >> You may have seen Rebecca Shaw’s The Guardian article that went viral, >> thanks to the headline, ‘I knew one day I’d have to watch powerful men burn >> the world down—I just didn’t expect them to be such losers.’ She starts >> with, ‘Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg’s desperation to be cool as they suck >> up to Donald Trump is so cringe it makes my skin crawl.” She ends with, >> “It’s time for us to start getting revenge on the nerds.” >> >> It’s time for the revenge of the adpeople. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 9:55 AM Charles Haynes via Silklist < >> [email protected]> wrote: >> >>> that article is paywalled, but if the online spaces you frequent aren't >>> meeting your needs - find new ones. There are heaps. I spend more time in >>> WhatsApp groups and Discord channels than those captured saturated places. >>> >>> The internet is dead, long live the internet. >>> >>> On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 at 12:18, Udhay Shankar N via Silklist < >>> [email protected]> wrote: >>> >>>> >>>> This piece, and others like it, remind me of what two separate >>>> listmembers (Cory Doctorow and Heather Madrone) have suggested at different >>>> times - we might need to save our old analog modems for when we need to >>>> reboot the internet. >>>> >>>> More to the point, the internet, for me, has always been more about >>>> community than anything else. Which is one big reason why I continue on >>>> spaces like this very list. >>>> >>>> Thoughts? >>>> >>>> Udhay >>>> ___________________________________ >>>> >>>> https://www.wired.com/story/let-the-internet-die/ >>>> >>>> Please Let the Internet Die >>>> >>>> Online spaces are captured by oligarchs and saturated with slop—and >>>> they’re exacerbating humanity’s worst impulses. It’s time to start over. >>>> >>>> (and lots more in this vein) >>>> -- >>>> Silklist mailing list >>>> [email protected] >>>> https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist >>>> >>> -- >>> Silklist mailing list >>> [email protected] >>> https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist >>> >> >> >> -- >> *Cindy Gallop* >> Consultant + Founder/CEO >> >> >> >> MakeLoveNotPorn Academy is now live in early-stage beta: >> https://www.makelovenotporn.academy/ >> >> You can make tax-deductible donations/donate from Donor Advised Funds to >> help us grow and scale MakeLoveNotPorn Academy >> <https://www.makelovenotporn.academy/>: donate here via non-profit >> Inspire Access <https://givebutter.com/InspireAccessxMLNP>. >> >> Watch my SXSW London 26-min keynote 'How Sex Education Can Help End >> Gender Violence And Bring Back Love' >> <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOnymx5eTi8> >> >> Listen to Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway: Sex, Porn And Knowing The >> Difference With Cindy Gallop >> <https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-prof-g-show-with-scott-galloway/id1498802610?i=1000575745417> >> >> Book me to speak >> <http://www.robinsonspeakers.com/cindy-gallop-speaker-speakers-bureau> Hire >> me to coach/consult <https://cindygallop.com/> | Connect with me on >> LinkedIn <https://www.linkedin.com/in/cindygallop/> Follow me on >> Instagram <https://www.instagram.com/cindygallop/> Follow me on Twitter >> <https://twitter.com/cindygallop> >> > -- > Silklist mailing list > [email protected] > https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist > -- Jon Lebkowsky (@jonl) Cofounder and Cohost, Plutopia News Network <https://plutopia.io> Writes at https://unshaved.substack.com/ | Website <https://weblogsky.com> | Bluesky <https://bsky.app/profile/jonl.bsky.social> | LinkedIn <http://www.linkedin.com/in/jonlebkowsky> | Facebook <http://www.facebook.com/jonlebkowsky> | Tumblr <http://weblogsky.tumblr.com/> | W <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Lebkowsky>ikipedia <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Lebkowsky> | LinkTree <https://linktr.ee/jonlebkowsky>
-- Silklist mailing list [email protected] https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist
