No, not at all. My op-ed is about the giant tech platforms getting
enshittified, how the ad industry has enabled that, and how the industry
should be using its financial power to change that for the benefit of all.

On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 10:19 AM Charles Haynes <[email protected]>
wrote:

> Wait, so this article is about the poor advertisers getting enshittified?
>
> I could tell war stories about the early days of ads at Google and how
> Larry had this vision of relevant ads adding value to the user experience.
> My arguments with the ads folks about how brand ads were evil and buying
> DoubleClick was the beginning of the end, but no.
>
> Let's just say I'm not shedding any tears about how hard online
> advertisers have it.
>
> — Charles
>
> On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 at 22:09, Cindy Gallop <[email protected]>
> wrote:
>
>> Apologies - article cut and pasted below for those interested:
>>
>> *Published in Campaign Asia Pacific Jan 20, 2025:*
>>
>> In the past couple of weeks, Mark Zuckerberg has shown us exactly who he
>> is.
>>
>> Meta has axed fact-checking and content moderation, with, in its internal
>> guidelines, some truly horrific statements of exactly what kind of hate
>> speech is now considered acceptable—in line with right-wing Silicon Valley
>> billionaires’ belief in ‘free speech for me but not for thee’. It’s
>> abandoning all pretence at DEI in its hiring and retention policies.
>> Zuckerberg has said that he feels Meta needs more "masculine energy",
>> because it’s good if a culture "celebrates aggression a bit more". Like his
>> fellow tech titans Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos, he’s kneeling at Trump’s feet,
>> kissing the ring, and obeying in advance.
>>
>> There’s never been a better time for the advertising industry to show
>> exactly who we are. But this isn’t an appeal for our industry to ‘do the
>> right thing’. Yes, we should, but I’m under no illusion that such an appeal
>> would actually work. Instead, this is an appeal for our industry to do four
>> things that will make agencies, holding companies and our clients a lot
>> more money.
>>
>> Do I have your attention now?
>>
>> *1. Flex our financial muscle*
>>
>> We’ve colluded in our own devaluation for decades—never more than with
>> the Silicon Valley giants. People value you at the value you are seen to
>> put on yourself, and we have not understood and projected the extraordinary
>> value that we have. We are the business model for the internet. We are the
>> reason Meta makes the billions it does. We are the reason for Mark
>> Zuckerberg’s net worth, and why he wields the power he does. He would not
>> be where he is today without advertising.
>>
>> But we gave that power away. For years, we’ve been pathetically grateful
>> that these platforms have allowed us to advertise on them, rather than
>> realising we’re in a position to call the shots. So—time to bring some
>> ‘masculine energy’ and some ‘aggression’ to the table, to do the deals we
>> want on our terms. Because without us, Meta and every other giant tech
>> platform that relies on advertising is screwed.
>>
>> *2. Be creative about what WE want *
>>
>> Instead of automatically going, “We have to be on——why not start from
>> the other end? We pride ourselves on extremely ingenious strategy and
>> highly creative execution. Use that ingenuity and creativity to decide what
>> the optimum brand experience/use of technology/campaign would be for our
>> clients, demand that, and set our own terms and conditions. We’re entirely
>> capable as an industry of developing far more creatively compelling ad
>> products and approaches than the ones we’re being forcefed.
>>
>> *3. Protect our consumers *
>>
>> In a January 14 article by Katie Notopoulos for Business Insider titled,
>> ‘Mark Zuckerberg says he wants more ‘masculine energy’ at Meta. So why
>> don’t more men use Facebook?’, she writes, “I do worry that people have
>> forgotten something that seems clear to me: Facebook is powered by feminine
>> energy.”
>>
>> Research shows that women are more active on Facebook and Instagram than
>> men. Meta is what it is today because of its female users. And women, let
>> us not forget, are our target for all advertising—as the primary purchasers
>> and influencers of purchases of everything.
>>
>> Content moderation keeps girls and women safe. Remove it, and sexism,
>> misogyny and rape culture run rampant unchecked.
>>
>> We make more money when we protect our consumers, stand up for them, and
>> demand better user experiences for them that keep them safe, happy, and
>> more receptive to the messages we and our clients want to send them, and
>> the brands and products we and our clients want them to buy.
>>
>> *4. Fund the female lens on advertising and tech *
>>
>> Six years ago, I spoke at Social Media Week New York, where I told the
>> audience that existing social media platforms, no matter how gigantic,
>> could be disrupted and toppled by the female/Black/of
>> colour/LGBTQ/disabled/’other’ founders who build the safe social platforms
>> of the future. That opportunity is even greater now, as the recent success
>> of BlueSky demonstrates.
>>
>> For years I’ve exhorted the women of the ad industry to build adtech
>> ventures—because adtech is as male-dominated as advertising and tech. We
>> are constantly targeted and sold to through the male lens—when we know how
>> to sell to ourselves.
>>
>> This isn’t just something I advocate for—I’m doing this myself because I
>> see the huge opportunity. I shared my idea for HereForTheAds in my Cannes
>> Lions keynote last year on ‘How To Change Advertising For the Better,
>> Fast’—it’s adtech designed to sell by making people love ads. Shocker,
>> right?
>>
>> Now is the time for our industry to invest in a different future for
>> advertising—because we have not even begun to see how much safer, better,
>> happier, more effective, and more lucrative that future could be when it’s
>> powered by feminine energy, designed and built through the female lens at
>> scale.
>>
>> You may have seen Rebecca Shaw’s The Guardian article that went viral,
>> thanks to the headline, ‘I knew one day I’d have to watch powerful men burn
>> the world down—I just didn’t expect them to be such losers.’ She starts
>> with, ‘Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg’s desperation to be cool as they suck
>> up to Donald Trump is so cringe it makes my skin crawl.” She ends with,
>> “It’s time for us to start getting revenge on the nerds.”
>>
>> It’s time for the revenge of the adpeople.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 9:55 AM Charles Haynes via Silklist <
>> [email protected]> wrote:
>>
>>> that article is paywalled, but if the online spaces you frequent aren't
>>> meeting your needs - find new ones. There are heaps. I spend more time in
>>> WhatsApp groups and Discord channels than those captured saturated places.
>>>
>>> The internet is dead, long live the internet.
>>>
>>> On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 at 12:18, Udhay Shankar N via Silklist <
>>> [email protected]> wrote:
>>>
>>>>
>>>> This piece, and others like it, remind me of what two separate
>>>> listmembers (Cory Doctorow and Heather Madrone) have suggested at different
>>>> times - we might need to save our old analog modems for when we need to
>>>> reboot the internet.
>>>>
>>>> More to the point, the internet, for me, has always been more about
>>>> community than anything else. Which is one big reason why I continue on
>>>> spaces like this very list.
>>>>
>>>> Thoughts?
>>>>
>>>> Udhay
>>>> ___________________________________
>>>>
>>>> https://www.wired.com/story/let-the-internet-die/
>>>>
>>>> Please Let the Internet Die
>>>>
>>>> Online spaces are captured by oligarchs and saturated with slop—and
>>>> they’re exacerbating humanity’s worst impulses. It’s time to start over.
>>>>
>>>> (and lots more in this vein)
>>>> --
>>>> Silklist mailing list
>>>> [email protected]
>>>> https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist
>>>>
>>> --
>>> Silklist mailing list
>>> [email protected]
>>> https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist
>>>
>>
>>
>> --
>> *Cindy Gallop*
>> Consultant + Founder/CEO
>>
>>
>>
>> MakeLoveNotPorn Academy is now live in early-stage beta:
>> https://www.makelovenotporn.academy/
>>
>> You can make tax-deductible donations/donate from Donor Advised Funds to
>> help us grow and scale MakeLoveNotPorn Academy
>> <https://www.makelovenotporn.academy/>: donate here via non-profit
>> Inspire Access <https://givebutter.com/InspireAccessxMLNP>.
>>
>> Watch my SXSW London 26-min keynote 'How Sex Education Can Help End
>> Gender Violence And Bring Back Love'
>> <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOnymx5eTi8>
>>
>> Listen to Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway: Sex, Porn And Knowing The
>> Difference With Cindy Gallop
>> <https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-prof-g-show-with-scott-galloway/id1498802610?i=1000575745417>
>>
>> Book me to speak
>> <http://www.robinsonspeakers.com/cindy-gallop-speaker-speakers-bureau> Hire
>> me to coach/consult <https://cindygallop.com/> |  Connect with me on
>> LinkedIn <https://www.linkedin.com/in/cindygallop/> Follow me on
>> Instagram <https://www.instagram.com/cindygallop/> Follow me on Twitter
>> <https://twitter.com/cindygallop>
>>
>

-- 
*Cindy Gallop*
Consultant + Founder/CEO



MakeLoveNotPorn Academy is now live in early-stage beta:
https://www.makelovenotporn.academy/

You can make tax-deductible donations/donate from Donor Advised Funds to
help us grow and scale MakeLoveNotPorn Academy
<https://www.makelovenotporn.academy/>: donate here via non-profit Inspire
Access <https://givebutter.com/InspireAccessxMLNP>.

Watch my SXSW London 26-min keynote 'How Sex Education Can Help End Gender
Violence And Bring Back Love' <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOnymx5eTi8>

Listen to Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway: Sex, Porn And Knowing The
Difference With Cindy Gallop
<https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-prof-g-show-with-scott-galloway/id1498802610?i=1000575745417>

Book me to speak
<http://www.robinsonspeakers.com/cindy-gallop-speaker-speakers-bureau> Hire
me to coach/consult <https://cindygallop.com/> |  Connect with me on
LinkedIn <https://www.linkedin.com/in/cindygallop/> Follow me on Instagram
<https://www.instagram.com/cindygallop/> Follow me on Twitter
<https://twitter.com/cindygallop>
-- 
Silklist mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist

Reply via email to