Please allow me to make several observations on the Rosemary Jacobs case. First, it may be safely presumed that Mrs. Jacobs was not the ONLY person in the world who took this nasal medication. There are likely millions of others who took it. But if the product she took is the cause of her color change, then where are the millions of blue people as could be the only valid evidence of such a claim? Mrs. Jacobs is guilty of "Post hoc, ergo propter hoc", i.e., "after this, therefore because of this", i.e., I drank milk and got cancer.... ergo milk is a carcinogen.
Second, and along the same lines, if Mrs. Jacobs claim is true, WHERE are the millions of blue people today who should be turning blue from the use of this dangerous colloidal silver? Its use is exploding, yet where are all the blue people? Were her story true, the totalitarians at Washington D.C. would have made a separate status for them as "people of color", and have extended special rights and status to them. Third, suppose there is some validity to her claim, but that it is only a remote possibility that these substances can cause this effect. Then must we not trace the effect to some other cause, or combination of causes, and not ONLY to colloidal silver? Suppose that colloidal silver causes this effect when combined with other substances? Is that a valid justification to vilify its use? If so, then we ought to ban chlorine bleach, because if added to ammonia it makes a deadly gas that will kill you. Or suppose that some pre-existing health complication causes the body to fail to properly metabolize the CS such that it causes this resulting pigmentation, will the disinterested enthusiasts at the FDA ban Tylenol because it shouldn't be taken during pregnancy? Until such factors can be determined, it is obvious that CS cannot bear the blame for the result. It appears to me that the whole claim is utterly invalid, and that it is just one more attempt to exterminate a powerful competitor to pharmaceutical interests who cannot patent those substances that HEAL. God made healing substances such that they are natural, and therefore unable to be patented, so as to evict such people imposing themselves in oppression. Such men, therefore, attempt to overthrow his order. Charles -----Original Message----- From: Michael C Slivinski [SMTP:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, June 21, 1998 8:36 AM To: [email protected]; [email protected] Subject: Re: Colloidal Silver (The Jacobs story) Hello All and for Nancy, here is the ref refered to below: http://www.tomifobia.com/previous/rosemary.html mike slivinski At 07:30 PM 6/20/98 -0400, you wrote: >Is this the "blue lady?" If not, please site a reference; >I'd like to see this page. > >If it's the woman I'm thinking of, I don't think she used >colloidal silver. I think it was a >prescription silver salt in which case the ppm >(concentration) and the particle size would have been far >greater than that of the CS we generally refer to here. >What we take is not much higher than what's considered >acceptable for daily silver derived from water and foods we >eat. > >Presenting CS as though it is the same as silver salts is >like saying a raisin is the same as a prune. I read a whole >medical article about the supposed dangers of CS, but there >was no real data pertaining to CS; it all was evidence based >on silver salts and protein silver in high concentrations. >(The reference is on my web page, it's a review of >literature by Fung, et. al. from the Journal of Toxicology.) > >Sincerely, >Nancy > >http://www.freeyellow.com/members2/silver-works (get a free >web page there if you can use one.) >-----Original Message----- >From: Michael C Slivinski <[email protected]> >To: [email protected] <[email protected]> >Date: Saturday, June 20, 1998 1:00 PM >Subject: Re: Colloidal Silver (The Jacobs story) > > >>Hello All, >>I looked at Rosmary Jacob's, Web Page, and just wanted to >comment that it is >>interesting that they site the many cases of success using >CS as anecdotal. >> >>But when they site her case it is not considered anecdotal >in the sense of: >> (where are the many others cases like hers that have had >experienced cs >>poisoning - argyric). >> >>It is important to know what else she took during her >period of illness >>that might be giving her this appearance/symtoms through >the years. >> >>We know certain medications and herbal combinations cause >side effects and the >>doctor wants too blame the herbs and the nutritionists want >to blame the drugs. >> >>It is both obviously... well, maybe not obvious to some >people. >> >>Just a side story.... a friend of mind did some serious >carrot jucing and his >>skin turned an almost light brown orange color and he was >seeing a doctor for >>a required physical checkup and the doctor says... oh the >color is the carrot >>pigment in his body. My friend says... gee! a friend of >mine jucies a lot of >>spinach and greens and his skins not green!! >> >>Thanks mike slivinski -- The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: [email protected] -or- [email protected] with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the subject: line. To post, address your message to: [email protected] List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>
<<application/ms-tnef>>
