Terry Chamberlin wrote:

> Recently there were posts between Marshall and Ole Bob
> concerning what causes argyria. Marshall posted
> several websites to support the statements he made. I
> looked over each of them. His points about argyria
> being caused by ionic and not colloidal silver are
> examples of the confusion that occurs repeatedly on
> this list from using words with different definitions.
>
> I find a great deal of the discussion here to
> sometimes be confusing because there have been no
> agreed-upon definitions of the words we use, different
> definitions are used than the rest of the scientific
> world uses, and two people will be talking apples and
> oranges without knowing it.
>
> I regularly see listers using *colloidal* as being
> different than *ionic*, even though absolutely
> everything we make is ionic. I would like to see a
> description of how to make a colloidal silver with
> electricity in which the silver particles do not have
> a charge. IONIC means “an atom or group of atoms that
> have a charge”.
>
> http://www.ozoneservices.com/glossary/i/ion.htm
> http://herh.ednet.ns.ca/Teachers/FarrellL/AtomicTheoryFAQ.htm#10
> http://ic-www.arc.nasa.gov/ic/projects/remote-agent/activities/pofo/docs/Propulsion/1-what-is-an-ion.html
>
> Marshall’s claim that only “ionic” silver causes
> argyria and not “colloidal” silver is based on a
> specific description of the mechanism of argyria that
> he accepts as valid. After perusing the sites Marshall
> posted, I could not find that description. The idea
> that only ionic silver salts cause argyria after they
> have reached the capillaries of the skin and are
> exposed to sunlight (which causes them to darken in
> color) has a logical sound to it, but it has some
> difficulties. I so far have not been able to find any
> medical resource that attributes the formation of
> argyria to that mechanism.

How about:

http://www.thedoctorsdoctor.com/diseases/argyria.htm

Argyria: the intradermal "photograph," a manifestation of passive 
photosensitivity. .... Similarities are
demonstrated between the darkening of the skin and the darkening of a 
photographic film following light
exposure. In both instances, colorless silver salts and compounds present in an 
inert matrix (collagen versus
gelatin) are reduced by incident light to black metallic silver.

This passive photosensitivity reaction leads to silver tattooing of the 
light-exposed skin and to
photographic imaging in the film.

Or:

www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxprofiles/tp146-c2.pdf and 
cira.ornl.gov/documents/SILVER.pdf
The skin discoloration of humans with argyria may be caused by a photoreduction 
of silver chloride to
metallic silver.

> If only silver “ions” cause
> argyria, how did the European Royalty get argyria from
> ingesting metallic silver powder?

What evidence is there that they did.  Blue Bloods could mean a lot of things, 
and most likely has nothing to
do with silver.

> Marshall said, “Can
> you name any other form of silver besides a salt or
> compound that can cause argyria and the process by
> which it could do so?” Well, metallic silver powder is
> one. One possible explanation is that the stomach’s
> digestive acid converted some of the silver powder to
> a silver salt. Since all ingested silver must pass
> through the stomach and its digestive acid bath (which
> apparently turns it into a silver salt), why would
> “ionic” silver (which is all that we make) be
> specified as the causative factor? If stomach acid
> does not convert metallic/colloidal silver into a salt
> form, how explain the argyria from drinking silver
> powder?

Can you cite an example of one getting argyria from ingested silver power?  You 
can get it by breathing it
into the lungs, that is proven, and also easily explainable since the body 
produces H2O2 which reacts with
the silver and changes it to silver oxide and silver hydroxide which is then 
absorbed through the lung tissue
into the blood stream.

> And it completely begs the question of cases
> of argyria caused by inhaling silver powder, or
> applying silver compounds to the skin, sinuses and
> other mucous membranes.

Those all enter the blood stream as silver compounds, so there is no puzzle 
about them.

>
>
> The medical establishment doesn’t know what actually
> CAUSES argyria, they only know what happens before it
> appears (ingesting huge amounts of silver nitrate,
> etc.). I have not seen a description of the mechanism
> of argyria that is comprehensive enough to account for
> all the various ways that argyria is contracted.

I think they do.  Can you give me an example that does not fall within the 
theory?  Remember that silver
metal WILL be oxidized to silver oxide and hydroxide in the lungs, so even with 
powdered metal in the lungs,
we still end up with ionic silver in the blood.

>
>
> We still seem to be differentiating between particles
> of one size and particles of another by calling the
> one “colloidal” and the other “ionic”, when actually,
> they are all ionic.
>

I am not convinced that the presence of a zeta potential is equivalent to an 
ion.  First of all, silver
particles are all going to be crystals, and I don't think a crystal is ever 
considered an ion. Basically a
zeta potential is much less than the charge of an ion. It is like a balloon 
that is charged up and will stick
to the wall, and repell other balloons, but the balloon is NOT an ion.  If the 
particle were to be an ion,
then it would have to have a charge equal to the number of atoms in the 
particle, but the charge is much less
than that.  http://www.silver-colloids.com/Tutorials/Intro/zetaintro.html goes 
into what a zeta potential is
and how it arises.

I am going to ask some chemistry experts to clarify this for us.

>
> To make a silver preparation in which the particles
> are so small that they make no color or have much or
> any Tyndall is to have particles that are billionths
> of a meter (nanometer) in size, which is called,
> accurately, nanosilver. Nanosilver cannot be made with
> any compounds resulting because the particles would be
> too large to be nanometer in size. Nanosilver cannot
> be made with anything but the purest silver and the
> purest water. Is that not what we do? If you brew a
> solution long enough to cause a yellow or gold color,
> the solution is still pure, but the particles are not
> nanometer in size. Nanosilver is, by definition, a
> pure silver preparation with silver particles measured
> in nanometers. It must be pure to even be made.
>
> As long as we make crystal clear CS/EIS, a large part
> of it will be Nanosilver.
>

That is correct.

>
> There is no evidence whatsoever that it is even
> possible to cause argyria from any amount or any
> application of Nanosilver.

As I have pointed out, nanosilver, that is silver particles or silver crystals 
in the nanometer range, or
colloidal silver does not cause argyria, but actually prevents it.

> Nanosilver is not affected
> by heat, cold, sunlight, magnetism, etc., and is the
> most effective form of silver for combating pathogens,
> according to Dr. Robert H. Demling.

But is is affected by ph, and surfactants, which will cause the zeta potential 
to be reduced where they can
aggregate.

>
>
> www.cesil.com/leaderforchemist/articoli/inglese/7demlinging/7demlinging.htm

Interesting site. I will read it when I get a chance, and if I find anything 
interesting to comment on will
do so later.

Marshall

>
>
> Terry Chamberlin
>
>
>
>
>
> __________________________________________________________
> Find your next car at http://autos.yahoo.ca
>
> --
> The Silver List is a moderated forum for discussing Colloidal Silver.
>
> Instructions for unsubscribing are posted at: http://silverlist.org
>
> To post, address your message to: [email protected]
>
> Address Off-Topic messages to: [email protected]
>
> The Silver List and Off Topic List archives are currently down...
>
> List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>
>