________________________________
From: [email protected]
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Cristi
Starasciuc
Sent: Friday, January 29, 2010 8:47 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [sipX-dev] Regarding Mailbox preferences - active
greeting in sipXconfig / sipXIvr (XX-6702)
Hi,
Regarding an older issue:
http://track.sipfoundry.org/browse/XX-6702 - Changing greeting type via
IVR wipes out IMAP information in mailboxprefs.xml
It was decided that sipXconfig would not generate
mailboxprefs.xml anymore and move email/imap information in
validusers.xml.
Damian commited a change for this issue in late October 2009,
but left the issue open with a comment that "sipXconfig/sipXivr still
need to exchange information about voicemail prompt".
I have decided (and it was agreed by Damian) to create a
sipXconfig REST interface that would get/set the active greeting. Right
now in sipXconfig the activegreeting is kept as a user setting and I
imagined sipXivr would use this REST to get/set the activegreeting
(basically, it gets/sets the user setting in sipXconfig).
However there's already a sipxIvr REST interface that does this
on IVR side.
Now I'm a bit confused.
Do we really need this REST interface in sipXconfig? Or should
sipXconfig just call sipXivr's REST to get/set the active greeting (get
for displaying in UI, set for propagating the change to IVR). I see one
problem here: if the IVR REST call fails for one reason or another, we
risk having inconsistent values for the active greeting.
The original sipXconfig proposal was to provide a REST interface
for sipXivr to use whenever it wants to deal with active greeting
(probably whenever it reads validusers.xml - which leads me to another
question: why isn't the active greeting written in validusers.xml).
Any clarification on this issue would be extremely helpful.
Thanks,
Ciuc
I'm confused as well. There are two comments in XX-6702:
- sipXconfig does not generate mailboxprefs.xml any more
(Damian)
- sipXconfig/sipXivr still need to exchange information about
the voicemail greeting (Damien)
As well Woof added a REST API in sipXivr to get/set the active
greeting setting but there are no
comments around that change.
So its not clear which component is meant to "own"
mailboxprefs.xml when it comes to updates.
If we had a common class that both sipXconfig and sipXivr used
to read/write the file then this wouldn't
be a problem since that class would "own" the data
representation. But we don't.
Comments ..??
Peter
_______________________________________________
sipx-dev mailing list [email protected]
List Archive: http://list.sipfoundry.org/archive/sipx-dev
Unsubscribe: http://list.sipfoundry.org/mailman/listinfo/sipx-dev
sipXecs IP PBX -- http://www.sipfoundry.org/
