A few comments:

-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1.5    Are milestones the same as run levels?
        
0. Fix typo "none, single-user, multi-user, multi-user-default, all "
                                                       ^^^^^^^
This should be multi-user-server
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1.12   Where are SMF logs?  Do I need to rotate them?

1. There should be a reference to /etc/svc/volatile.

     /etc/svc/volatile       Directory  where  svc.startd  stores
                             log  files  in early stages of boot,
                             before /var is mounted read-write.

2. You wrote:

        You can see the filename of the log for any service by invoking 

                # svcs -x <service> 

This doesn't work for services that are disabled.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1.13    Location of SMF files

3. Add "/etc/svc - repositories, logs"
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1.14    Other documentation for SMF outside the man pages

4. Add Solaris 10 System Administrator Collection >> System Administration 
Guide: Basic Administration
        "http://docs.sun.com/app/docs/doc/817-1985/6mhm8o5rq?q=817-1985&a=view";
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 2.13    How do I find out what is my system's default milestone?

5. Fix typo "If options/milestone does not exist, the default milstone is 
"all"."
                                                              ^^^^^^^^
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 2.14    How do I leave my current milestone?

6. Replace "# svcadm <new milestone>" by "# svcadm milestone <new milestone>"
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 2.16    How do I find out what processes are associated with my service?

7. I prefer "svcs -pv" as it also returns the contract ids.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 2.17    How do I find see the process privilege sets of my service?

8. Fix title "How do I find see"
                       ^^^^^^^^
-------------------------------------------------------------
Section 2.18    How do I assign my service to run in a project?

9. You wrote "In general, you should not create this property just by itself;" 
but
what is the property you're referring to?
--------------------------------------------------------------

Nice work!
-- Renaud



-------- Original Message  --------
Subject: [smf-discuss] SMF FAQ Update
From: Christine Tran <christine.t...@sun.com>
To: smf-discuss at opensolaris.org
Cc: Christine.Tran at Sun.COM
Date: Fri Mar 30 2007 00:35:35 GMT+0200 (CEST)

> 
> I have attached the proposed changes and addition to the SMF FAQ. 
> delta.txt is the change, smf_faq_next.txt is the whole thing.
> 
> * denotes changes to the original.
> X denotes proposal to withdraw.
> No mark is new.
> 
> I want to withdraw 3.12 because the description for this case is 
> confined, and the answer given is unsatisfactory.
> 
> I have doubts about 1.13, I think saying that /var/svc/log is the 
> location for SMF log is unnecessary.
> 
> I do not want to see this FAQ become the kitchen sink in that at every 
> revision more stuff is thrown in but nothing is ever taken out.  There 
> should be an attempt to keep this relevant and up-to-date.  A user 
> should not have to slog through pages of out-dated information to find 
> one thing he needs.  So, I'm all for trimming, trimming, and trimming.
> 
> I realize there are *still* stuff from Bernd's old suggestion list that 
> I have not included.  I just don't have time.  Everything new has been 
> tested, and as far as I can tell, they work.
> 
> Additions are made by appending to the old section to make it easy on 
> whoever has to update the FAQ page.  Therefore, you may not see 
> questions presented in the most logical order.  For example, Section 1. 
> GENERAL starts out very nicely with files, directories, and commands, 
> and then leaps a mile to end up with location of files and 
> documentation.  I'm sorry about that, it just takes too much work move 
> the questions around and doctor up the numbers.
> 
> Please send comments to smf-discuss, I don't need to be cc'd.
> 
> Thanks!
> 
> CT
> 
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> 1. GENERAL
> * 1.3   Short listing of relevant SMF man pages
> * 1.5   Are milestones the same as run levels?
> 1.12    Where are SMF logs?  Do I need to rotate them?
> 1.13    Location of SMF files
> 1.14    Other documentation for SMF outside the man pages
> 
> 
> 2. ADMINISTRATIVE
> 2.13    How do I find out what is my system's default milestone?
> 2.14    How do I leave my current milestone?
> 2.15    How do I create my own milestone?
> 2.16    How do I find out what processes are associated with my service?
> 2.17    How do I find see the process privilege sets of my service?
> 2.18    How do I assign my service to run in a project?
> 2.19    How do I set environment variables for my service?
> 
> 
> 3. TROUBLESHOOTING
> X 3.12  Why is network/physical hanging?
> 
> 4. WRITING SMF MANIFESTS
> * 4.1   How do I write an SMF manifest?
> 4.7     What does a timeout_seconds value of '0' or -1' mean?
> 4.8     What is the inetconv property group used for?
> 4.9     How do I restrict my service to have only the privileges it needs?
> 4.10    How do I assign my service to run in a project in a manifest?
> 4.11    Where do I put manifests that I've written?
> 
> 
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> _______________________________________________
> smf-discuss mailing list
> smf-discuss at opensolaris.org


Reply via email to