There is a real easy way to improve the contests with out resorting to the
non flying skill of the dork landing. Make the flying tasks more
challenging. the problem is that the rules for most TD type events were
developed years ago well before optimized modern ships were conceived.
I would submit that it is a comment on the lack of incentive to change rules
to suit modern ship design. I always considered  a 7 minute "duration"
oxymoronic anyway. I think there is reluctance to change the rules because
it would make contests, "flying contests" instead of "launch/landing"
contests, which seems to suit the American mindset. Besides, there seem to
be more people willing to practice the launching and landing than actual
flying skills.
I have to agree with the international view that dork landings have no value
in a soaring contest. What indeed is the point, to see who has the strongest
airframe? If you want to play darts, get a dart board, if you want to fly,
learn to use the skills necessary to fly an aircraft.
I have seen many pilots who have transitioned from TD type flying and
aircraft to scale ships, many have difficulty with basic flying skills such
as centering in a thermal, flying at the appropriate speed, judging
distance, using their left thumb, and flying a landing approach parallel to
themselves. Why not have contests that developed skills akin to those
required to fly full scale aircraft? Some R/C pilots complain that the
public view their sailplanes as toys. Perhaps if we did not fly them like
toys the impression would change.
In Europe (not to compare apples to oranges) it is not unusual to see 10,000
spectators at a model air show. Do they come to watch men circle lawn darts
for 7-10 minutes then dork them into the turf?
I suppose the real question is where do pilots see R/C soaring going in the
next 10 years? Will the status quo remain with hopelessly outdated rules
applying to state of the art designs, or will someone have the foresight to
admit we need to evolve the events to the future. One difficulty is that
sponsors and manufacturers have a vested interest in keeping things the way
they are. Remember that. And I would submit that many pilots are threatened
by any changes that would force them to develop  skills than those that they
are already comfortable with.
admittedly biased, and respectfully yours,
john D.

 John Derstine
E-mail; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Scale Soaring: http://www.Geocities.com/~scalesoar

-----Original Message-----
From: FRED SAGE [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
Sent: Monday, December 18, 2000 1:04 AM
To: Walter Lynch; RCSE
Subject: [RCSE] Landings: "a complete waste of time"?



 Walter;

The reason for precision landings  in AMA TD contests is to determine the
winner,  or more specifically to identify the more capable or proficient
pilots.  Given the current state of the art with design and construction,
making whatever flight task is decreed is almost routine,  at least here in
SOCAL.  In fact,  during the last two SC2 contests of this year ,  three 10
minute rounds were declared. The conditions at the SWSA contest were
particularly brutal  with strong down wind/cross wind launches and landings
and intermittent showers.   However,  both contests still came down to who
could land the best.  Without including the scoring importance of landings
in a TD contest,   almost all pilots  would end up with near identical and
near perfect scores.  What's the sense of competing in a contest where
everyone has an identical score?  I like to call that a non-contest contest;
really more of a fun fly.  I also think it's logical to prescribe some
relative importance to precision landings as that's the area of flight were
some measure of skill and proficiency is required.  Almost anyone can
stagger around the sky for several minutes;  you don't even have to be
smooth or efficient.  Just find some lift and go hang out.  However,  it
takes a skilled  and practiced pilot to hit the spot on time and every time.
Remembering back to my days in Naval Aviation,  all the pilots were allowed
to fill the flight schedule during routine day carrier operations.  However,
on a black ass night with a pitching deck and during blue water operations
(no bingo fields),  only the A team was allowed to fly.  To do otherwise
would have been suicidal.  I also don't agree with the comment that coming
close to the spot every time is purely luck.  If that were the case,  the
same pilots wouldn't be consistently winning.  Names like Daryl Perkins or
Joe Wurts would be no more recognizable than the typical sportsman pilot.
Now I'll admit,  I like the current system.   The difficulty of the typical
AMA TD landing is what keeps me coming back for more.   If  TD contest
results were determined only by maxing flight times,  I think I'd quickly
get bored and drop out.  However,  I keep coming back because there's no way
of making a perfect landing every time.  I also can't think of a better way
of taking the luck out of contest scores.  Going to more called flight order
contests would certainly give you some scoring dispersion  without relying
on landing scores,  but the luck factor really enters into a called flight
order contest.  If you're called to fly during a down cycle,  you might as
well have stayed home no matter how talented you are.  Flying more man on
man contests with even longer flight tasks (15 minutes as in F3J finals)
would also weed out the less capable pilots without relying on landing
scores,  but the typical glider club or AMA contest isn't staffed or
equipped to run a man on man contest.  It takes six or seven winches and
hopefully retrievers to get a six man heat into the air at the same time.
Perhaps the best way to relegate the importance of landing scores for AMA TD
contests would be to use the FAI standard and eliminate landing skegs.
However,  until the AMA changes it's rules and everyone complies,   you're
going to end up flying in some contests with skegs and some without.   Also,
since a TD contest is often the first competitive exposure for neophyte
pilots,  there's something to be said for skegs as a safety issue.  I've
seen many pilots saved from being hit with their gliders only because the
skeg stopped the glider before sliding through.

I guess I've outlined a situation without offering a solution.  Please
notice that I didn't call this discussion a problem as I don't view it as
such.  Of course,  the real solution is to go practice your landings until
you become proficient.  Then we'll be referring to your name instead of DP
or JW.

FS

RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and 
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to