John;
I could support a no skeg policy as it comes closer to my personal opinion of the
ideal competitive venue. Pilots with highly developed skills and proficiency would
still win because they could stop the glider close to the spot even without skegs.
Other pilots with less ability would see a wider scoring dispersion because they would
do a lot of sliding through. The luck factor with landing scores would be largely
eliminated as a good landing score would be the result of a well controlled approach
and not the result of a lucky stab at the spot with the skeg. However, before
adopting such a policy, at least three issues would have to be addressed and
resolved.
1. This mandate would have to come from the AMA and would restrict the use of skegs
during all AMA sanctioned TD contests nationwide. Otherwise, you'd be flying in a
contest one weekend where skegs are allowed and the next weekend you'd be flying where
skegs aren't allowed. Given a new AMA policy, over the period of the following year,
most local clubs would embrace the change and skegs wouldn't be allowed at any TD
competition.
2. Skegs as a safety issue would have to be overcome. Since a TD competition is
normally the novice pilots first exposure to competition and also includes a lot of
sportsman pilots, it's not unusual to see pilots flying through the landing zone and
hitting themselves or others. I personally have seen dozens of such incidents, some
with relatively serious results. I've seen bloodied shins, bruises on the torso
and lumps on the head. Landing skegs help to ameliorate these incidents as the
glider can at least be stopped before it hits anyone. Personally, I think this is
the most substantial argument for keeping skegs and this would probably be a hard
battle to win.
3. Most soaring pilots are somewhat independent people and hate being told what to
do. After seeing all the whining and carping about various rules on the RCSE, I
don't think there's a sufficient mandate for change. Most pilots would just view a
revision of the skeg policy as an AMA infringement on their individual right and
freedom to enjoy this wonderful hobby.
So, whereas I could certainly support a change to no skegs for TD competition, I
don't see it happening anytime soon.
Fred
RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]