I said I haven't bought one, but I've dealt with many of them, both from friends and Family (which is why I haven't bought one). I would think that after 20 years they would get their issues straightened out, but from what I've seen they haven't learned anything over the years. The last one I dealt with was about 6 months ago and I was shocked at how dated the driver panel seemed. I felt like I was dealing with windows 3.1 technology by the way the thing was put together. Using it just felt like the person or people who created it just didn't care how well it worked. If AMD (ATI) cards work for you, great, but it's going to take some pretty massive changes for me to seriously consider using them again.
I think with programs like C4d and Modo, the developers go out of their way to write their programs to work with them. I remember Modo 1.0 worked well with ATI (from what I heard on the forums), but it had a lot of problems with NVidia cards. I seem to remember that the developers were all using ATI cards at the time. From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Raffaele Fragapane Sent: Friday, April 19, 2013 12:37 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: AMD & MAXON Cinema 4D. I'm not an ATI fan, but if you haven't tried one in 20 years maybe you might be a bit unreasonable :) While drivers wise nVIDIA still has an edge, and usually every generation they are the top performer for a while longer (although that's a chasing game), AMD has been on top of bang for buck for quite a while, and once you find a decent driver you can stick with it for quite a while with good success, just they are fewer and further apart than nVIDIA's, which also has had many messed up releases. It's not healthy to be so strongly prejudiced, while I don't think it's there yet for me to consider as a viable alternative, but I also have some time invested in CUDA and none in OCL, AMD is worth keeping an eye out for, and it's far from the catastrophic experience it was five years ago on average. For the record, C4D has run absolutely flawlessly on ATI for year now, all the way back to the first radeons. On Fri, Apr 19, 2013 at 12:44 PM, Sam <[email protected]> wrote: My motto for video cards is "if it says ATI AMD on the outside it's crap on the inside". I don't care how fast a card is, if the drivers suck, the card is going to suck. ATI drivers have always sucked (first one I bought was about 20 years ago (it was also the last one I bought)) and it hasn't changed since AMD took over. I've had friends buy the cards because of the benchmarks and they have always had problems, and just recently I had to fix my niece's laptop because the latest AMD update made her 3d games unplayable (built her a computer with an NVIDIA card for Christmas so I would never have to deal with it again). I honestly have never known anyone who had an ATI card that was happy with it. From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Sven Constable Sent: Thursday, April 18, 2013 11:20 AM To: [email protected] Subject: RE: AMD & MAXON Cinema 4D. ".AMD FireProT W-Series is fully tested, certified & optimised for MAXON Cinema 4D." I don't buy that anymore. I bought a FirePro couple years ago (actually it was its predecessor named FireGL), just because AMD claimed the same for Softimage (fully certified, yeah right). They should have stated ".viewport glitches and selection hangs have been reduced somewhat..." :) From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Leoung O'Young Sent: Thursday, April 18, 2013 16:21 To: xsi Subject: AMD & MAXON Cinema 4D. Interesting development between Maxon and AMD Maxon is busy setting up partnerships, Adobe, and now AMD Now if only Autodesk will start doing some of this with Softimage, I will be a happy man http://www.animationxpress.com/images/AMD_FirePropacks_more_speed.html AMD FireProT W-Series packs more speed, power and performance to fuel stunning, cutting-edge 3D animations in MAXON Cinema 4D. -- Our users will know fear and cower before our software! Ship it! Ship it and let them flee like the dogs they are!
