Why Sudan should accept South Sudan’s financial package
Article
Comments (11)
email Email
print Print
pdfSave
separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation
By the European Coalition on Oil in Sudan (ECOS)
South Sudan’s proposal on oil is commercially sound and, with $8
billion in budget support, may be the best that Sudan can ever get.
Since their separation in July 2011, Sudan and South Sudan have been
negotiating bitterly about the way forward. Time is running short now.
South Sudan closed down its entire petroleum industry last January
after Sudan had started confiscating and even stealing its oil, and
now both countries are facing bankruptcy. Moreover, if they don’t sign
an agreement by 2 August, the UN Security Council may sanction them.
To break the deadlock, South Sudan made a detailed proposal on 22
July, called “Agreement on Friendly Relations & Cooperation”, which
deals with all outstanding issues, including border demarcation, a
solution for Abyei, and managing internal conflicts. Its key
component, however - a $ 7.5 per barrel transportation fee plus $ 8
billion in budget support - is about the restart of oil production and
the prevention of mutually assured bankruptcy.
On 25 July, Sudan rejected the proposal, arguing that it contained
“nothing new”, meanwhile lowering its demand for a transportation fee
of South Sudan’s oil from $ 36 to $ 32 per barrel. Assuming an
estimated production of 230.000 barrels per day at a price of $
90/100, this comes down to $ 2.7 billion a year, or 52% of South
Sudan’s expected future net revenue. The two proposals may be too far
apart to meet the UN Security Council’s deadline and both sides are
under heavy diplomatic pressure to give in. The challenge will be to
strike a deal that does not only relieve today’s immediate troubles,
but also satisfies the longer term interests of both governments and
will be supported by their constituencies. Such a deal will have to be
reasonable and equitable. Are they?
The key issues are the fee that South Sudan should pay Sudan for
transportation and handling of its crude, what to do with Sudan’s
assumed debt of $ 5 billion to South Sudan, and whether Sudan should
receive budget support from South Sudan.
The transportation fee must take into account the costs for the use of
pipelines, central processing facilities and marine terminals, as well
as a fee for transiting the territory of Sudan. South Sudan’s offer is
based on the current tariffs for Sudan’s internally produced own
crude, to which it adds a profit component and transit fee of $ 0.63
to $ 0.69 per barrel. This amounts to an average of $ 7.5 per barrel
in transportation fees or $ 1.7 million per day. Most of it would be
paid to the operators or owners of the petroleum infrastructure.
Sudan’s Government would annually receive $ 129 million in cash plus
the profit derived from the state oil company’s partial ownership of
key petroleum infrastructure. Commercially, this is a reasonable offer
and if two friendly countries were to sign such a deal this would go
unnoticed.
In addition, South Sudan is offering Sudan $ 8 billion, notably $ 3.03
billion budget support in cash to be paid over 3.5 years and $ 4.97
billion in immediate forgiveness for all claimed arrears. The cash
transfer part roughly equals 15% of the Government of South Sudan’s
expected annual revenue and would trim the State’s expected budget for
the coming 3.5 years down from $ 5,1 billion to $ $ 4.3 billion.
Sudan has rejected the offer, arguing quite rightly that there is no
such a thing as a right to be charged the same price as others are
getting, and that it is perfectly legal to demand whatever one finds
right. Sudan’s counter-proposal does not involve any direct budget
support by South Sudan. The core, a transportation fee of $ 32 per
barrel, is inspired by its acute budgetary needs rather than by
economical commonsense and amounts to $ 7.3 million per day, or $ 2.7
billion per year, 52% of South Sudan’s total Government revenue, to be
fully paid to Sudan’s Government. No details are given as to how the
companies are to be paid their share. It would be just about a
continuation of the arrangement for the 6 years before separation,
when Southern oil revenues were split 50-50.
Sudan has badly mismanaged its economy. Since 1999, and largely thanks
to South Sudan’s oil, it has spent extraordinary amounts of money on
its security apparatus and political patronage, borrowed a lot of
extra money, while neglecting economically sustainable investments.
Its failure to prepare its economy for a future without South Sudan’s
oil is causing acute financial stress and, according to some
observers, may even be threatening the National Congress Party’s hold
on power. South Sudan has also mismanaged its economy. The majority of
its budget goes to the security apparatus, the civil service, and bank
accounts of high ranking officials, rather than investment in future
economic growth. But all this doesn’t make it any more equitable if
South Sudan were to pay for Sudan’s budget deficit.
>From an outsider’s perspective, South Sudan’s proposal seems to be
reasonable. Whether it appears to be equitable will depend on one’s
perspective, but the enormous mutual benefit of any agreement may to
some extend compensate for the odd spectacle of a very poor country
subsidizing a slightly less poor country with which it is has been at
war for many years. South Sudan offers commercial conditions for
commercial activities, and government-to-government payments for the
non-commercial side of things. It has also thought about a management
system that is likely to prevent unnecessary disagreements along the
way. This seems to be a sensible approach for an agreement that only
makes sense if it holds for several years.
South Sudan offers to transfer 15% of its own revenues for a period of
3.5 years is unheard of in human history. It reflects the fact that a
refusal to allow the transit of southern crude would financially
strangle South Sudan. The Government of South Sudan hasn’t consulted
Parliament yet and will have a hard time defending its proposal
against a constituency that has no sympathy for Sudan’s leadership.
Clearly, the proposal will only partially solve Sudan’s acute
budgetary problems and may therefore not be enough of an incentive,
but it is likely to be close to the maximum that Sudan can obtain at
the negotiating table. Once people in South Sudan will start realizing
that their President Salva Kiir is offering a multi-billion dollar
lifeline to President Omar al-Bashir, his approval ratings are likely
to plummet.
Some observers are speculating that both governments are tacitly
hoping for the other to collapse first. This would be a nightmare
scenario. For now, South Sudan’s proposal seems to be the most
reasonable solution. And if it prevents the implosion of both states,
it may in some way even be the most equitable.
The European Coalition on Oil in Sudan (ECOS), established in 2001 and
lead by IKV Pax Christi, represents a large group of European
organizations working for peace and justice in South Sudan and Sudan.
ECOS calls upon the Governments and the business sector to ensure that
oil wealth contributes to peace and equitable development.
The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely
the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the
responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.
If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it
to [email protected]
Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication.
Please include your full name, relevant personal information and
political affiliations.
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.